Experts warn: Armenia's westward drift imperils statehood amid Moscow rift
Navigating between Scylla and Charybdis
INTERVIEWS 02 July 2024 - 16:52
Samir Ibrahimov |
Russian Deputy Prime Minister Alexei Overchuk, speaking at the 10th international forum "Primakov Readings," highlighted Armenia's increasing tilt towards the West and its potential ramifications.
"There is a well-known half-joke that Nikol Vovayevich uttered in one of his interviews. Asked when he would join the EU if he had the opportunity to choose for himself, Pashinyan joked: 'This year'." There are also discussions about holding a referendum on EU accession," Overchuk recalled.
Overchuk emphasized that benefits from Russia should be seen as contributions to security, warning of consequences if extra-regional players intervene in Armenia. This raises questions about Armenia's strategic direction and practical steps amid its EAEU membership discussions.
He also acknowledged existing grievances within Armenian society towards Russia. "There is such a perspective, and it should be understood," he remarked. Overchuk emphasized the incompatibility between the EU and the EAEU, suggesting that benefits derived from close ties with Russia should be viewed as contributions towards security and strategic depth. He cautioned that the involvement of external players could lead to consequences, stressing Russia's interest in maintaining stability and strong trade and fraternal relations with Armenia.
What consequences for Armenia on the part of the Russian Federation the Russian Deputy Prime Minister is talking about? What can they be expressed in? How long will the Armenian leadership be able to talk about the desire to get closer to the EU and at the same time do nothing in practice to leave the EAEU?
Foreign experts shared their thoughts on the matter with Caliber.Az.
Analyst and Director of the Institute of World Politics in Bishkek, Sheradil Baktygulov, pointed out significant trade figures to illustrate Armenia's economic ties.
He mentioned that in 2023, Armenia's trade with EAEU countries had grown by 42.7%, reaching a total of USD 7.6 billion. Notably, he highlighted that 90% of this trade volume, approximately $7.3 billion, was with Russia. In contrast, he noted that Armenia's trade turnover with EU countries in 2023 amounted to about $2.3 billion. He also pointed out that Armenia exported goods worth around $7 billion and imported goods valued at approximately $11 billion. According to him, Russia emerged as Armenia's largest trading partner, both in terms of imports and exports. He added that the UAE followed as the second-largest importer with about $1.4 billion, while China ranked second in terms of imports with approximately $900 million. He also provided a comparison, mentioning that the Netherlands held the largest share of imports from the EU at around $600 million, and Germany led in exports to Armenia with about $500 million.
He argues that Russian Deputy Prime Minister Alexei Overchuk, while not a diplomat, plays a crucial role in coordinating Russia's integration policies within the Eurasian space and its engagements in multilateral cooperation formats.
"Therefore, statements could be interpreted as a signal to Armenia to bargain. There are clear indications from Armenia in this regard. For instance, EU accession procedures do not include provisions for a referendum on membership, which Armenia has considered. Such referendums, even if conducted quarterly, would not facilitate EU accession. Moreover, Armenia would need to adhere to EU standards, necessitating substantial domestic reforms such as combating corruption, implementing human rights norms, and transitioning to a market economy. This would include enacting laws and potentially returning lands and homes to displaced ethnic Azerbaijanis, a step Armenia is currently unprepared for," the expert said.
He further added that Armenia is unwilling to meet these conditions to loosen Russia's influence, even with potential annual Western aid of $7 billion, and is adamantly opposed to returning lands and homes to Azerbaijanis, actively obstructing any such efforts. This stance suggests Armenia may violate a key requirement for EU membership.
"Ending ties with Moscow would lead to the breakdown of Armenian statehood. Armenia has traditionally had close relations with Moscow, second only to Belarus. Moreover, ordinary Russians sympathize with Armenia. For ordinary Russians, moving closer to the EU and distancing from the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU), the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) and Russia would signify Armenia turning against an ally. This is because the EU and the US have imposed the most sanctions on Russia, causing distress to both ordinary and non-ordinary Russian citizens. Therefore, regardless of how the Armenian authorities present their actions, they are already being perceived as a betrayal by Russia. Unfortunately, such actions can make Armenia appear as if it is siding with the enemy. This would require Armenia to publicly declare support for the ongoing Russian military operation, which would mark the end of the alliance between Armenia and Russia. In response, Russia would take corresponding measures across all areas of cooperation with Armenia. Western countries, particularly France, which strongly supports Armenia, would not be able to quickly compensate Armenia for the losses resulting from severing ties with Russia," Baktygulov believes.
However, he argues, the issue isn't about choosing between Russia or the EU.
"It's possible to cooperate with everyone. The main mistake Armenia makes is trying to favour one side at the expense of the other. Armenian authorities should focus on national prosperity rather than picking sides. Politicians likely understand this but continue confrontational policies with Russia to extract more benefits from either Russia or the EU. The real question is: who benefits from this, themselves or the people? Deceiving the hopes of ordinary people is dishonourable and ultimately leads to a political collapse in the medium term," Baktygulov emphasized.
Kazakhstani political analyst Aidar Amrebayev suggested that Overchuk's speech appears not just as a veiled threat but rather a "final warning" to Armenia regarding its potential pivot towards the West...
"The consequences could range widely: from mild sanctions affecting economic ties, which could significantly impact Armenia, heavily reliant on Russia, to the implementation of a hybrid special operation aimed at coercively redirecting the foreign policy orientation of 'former Soviet Armenia'... We've witnessed similar scenarios in other post-Soviet nations that ventured to adopt non-Russian foreign policies. The Armenian leadership faces a tough decision akin to navigating between Scylla and Charybdis," Amrebayev emphasized.
Caliber.Az
1
|
New Canadian envoy’s hastiness versus President Aliyev's acumen The interest behind envoy's one-sided question?
02 July 2024 - 18:22
|
2
|
Iran's pivotal presidential runoff: Pezeshkian vs. Jalili A new political era after Raisi’s death?
01 July 2024 - 18:00
|
3
|
Yerevan stalls Zangezur corridor: A "Peace Crossroads" to nowhere Hindering regional connectivity
02 July 2024 - 15:09
|
4
|
South Caucasus looking forward to new EU top officials’ activity Activity towards Azerbaijan to depend on some factors
01 July 2024 - 13:04
|
5
|
Russia destroys five Su-27 fighters at Ukraine's Myrhorod airfield VIDEO
02 July 2024 - 15:09
|
Belarus backs China's peace initiative for Ukraine conflict, Lukashenko tells Xi Jinping
04 July 2024 - 19:27
Putin confident in strengthening Moscow-Tehran relations despite Iran's elections
04 July 2024 - 19:11
Finland to implement stricter entry rules from September 1
04 July 2024 - 18:55
Azerbaijani leader concludes Kazakhstan visit
04 July 2024 - 18:47
Erdogan urges heightened international pressure on Israel
04 July 2024 - 18:40
Media: Pakistan prepares $2-3 billion investment portfolio for Azerbaijan
04 July 2024 - 18:25
Kazakh leader: SCO member states highly appreciate Azerbaijan's contribution
04 July 2024 - 18:10
Armenian former official slams incompetent government
04 July 2024 - 17:58
Israel faces Hezbollah's most intense attack since conflict's onset
04 July 2024 - 17:46
President Aliyev: Azerbaijan plays key role in North-South transport corridor development
Address at "SCO Plus" meeting in Astana04 July 2024 - 17:36
Georgia seeks to mend relations with US
04 July 2024 - 17:34
Ukrainian president rejects ceasefire proposal from Hungarian PM
04 July 2024 - 17:22
Q&A: Iran's runoff presidential elections amid historic low turnout
Reformists vs. hardliners04 July 2024 - 17:15
Putin discusses Qatar's potential entry into North-South transport corridor
04 July 2024 - 17:11
Azerbaijani troops engage in tactical exercises to boost readiness
PHOTO04 July 2024 - 16:58
China's economic leverage could end Ukraine war
Amid Russia's isolation04 July 2024 - 16:46
Experts debate Zangezur corridor's viability amid Armenia's futile "Crossroads of Peace"
Armenia's populism stifles regional development04 July 2024 - 16:34
German FM: Russia to remain Europe's biggest threat
04 July 2024 - 16:22
Ukraine’s Zelenskyy declines interview with US journalist Tucker Carlson
04 July 2024 - 16:10
UN Secretary-General António Guterres outlines expectations for COP29 in Baku
04 July 2024 - 15:58
French leader's allies urge him to stay off campaign trail
04 July 2024 - 15:46
Turkish army neutralizes over 1,300 terrorists in 2024 operations so far – Spokesperson
VIDEO04 July 2024 - 15:34
Azerbaijani MFA congratulates US on Independence Day
04 July 2024 - 15:22
Majority of Azerbaijanis advocate peace with Armenia
Poll findings04 July 2024 - 15:10
Kyrgyz leader to visit Azerbaijan for Turkic states summit
04 July 2024 - 14:57
China assumes SCO chairmanship
04 July 2024 - 14:41
Türkiye’s Kars hosts forum on "Return to Western Azerbaijan”
Calls for unified homeland return04 July 2024 - 14:26
France's interior minister to step down following snap parliamentary elections
04 July 2024 - 14:11
NATO concern grows over potential French far-right government entry
04 July 2024 - 14:02
Putin: Russia's proposal aims to achieve immediate cessation of hostilities
04 July 2024 - 13:51
Armenian PM sends security chief on official mission to UK
04 July 2024 - 13:39
Astana summit marks a pivotal moment for Azerbaijan-China strategic partnership
Why Asia matters?04 July 2024 - 13:27
Turkish Forces destroy over 30 terrorist locations in northern Iraq
MAP04 July 2024 - 13:15
Azerbaijani, Uzbek central banks ink Memorandum of Understanding
PHOTO04 July 2024 - 13:03
Azerbaijani President to attend "SCO plus" format meeting in Kazakhstan
PHOTO04 July 2024 - 12:55
SCO - catalyst for inclusive cooperation
Summit in Astana and “Shanghai Spirit”04 July 2024 - 12:51
Iran set to launch private-sector developed satellites
04 July 2024 - 12:39
China-Azerbaijan container traffic via Middle Corridor begins
PHOTO04 July 2024 - 12:27
Former minister: EU membership may be perilous for Armenia
04 July 2024 - 12:15
Azerbaijan-SCO: Charting visionary path forward
Fostering dialogue and cooperation04 July 2024 - 12:10