Generations of discrimination: Can slavery reparations revoke collective memory?
Experts cast doubt on Guterres' controversial atonement attempt
INTERVIEWS 30 March 2024 - 13:13
Samir Ibrahimov |
On March 25, Reuters reported on United Nations chief Antonio Guterres' call for reparations over the transatlantic trafficking of enslaved people as a way to tackle its legacy in today's society, including systemic racism.
From the 15th to the 19th century, at least 12.5 million Africans were kidnapped, forcibly transported by European ships and merchants and sold into slavery. Those who survived the brutal voyage ended up toiling on plantations in the Americas, mostly in Brazil and the Caribbean, while others profited from their labour.
In a statement to mark the UN International Day of Remembrance of the Victims of Slavery, Guterres said the past "laid the foundations for a violent discrimination system based on white supremacy."
"We call for reparatory justice frameworks to help overcome generations of exclusion and discrimination," Guterres said.
It is crucial to acknowledge that the descendants of African slaves primarily reside in the United States, but some also inhabit European countries, such as France.
If we examine Guterres' statements closely, we notice that he proposes that these individuals should receive monetary compensation, also known as "reparations," to help overcome the remnants of the slave trade in modern society, including systemic racism. However, can monetary compensation make the descendants of slaves forget about the atrocities that their ancestors faced and spontaneously develop positive feelings towards Caucasians? It's essential to remember that every individual is unique, and many black and white people treat each other with respect and without prejudice. On the other hand, some individuals hold racist views despite their race. Can monetary compensation truly change their beliefs? Additionally, who should provide these reparations, and what should be the amount of the payment? It's peculiar to hear such a vague proposal from the UN Secretary-General himself.
Foreign pundits shared their opinions on the matter with Caliber.Az.
American analyst Paul Goble, who previously served as a special advisor to the US Secretary of State, believes that the focus should be on combating racism and promoting the accurate remembrance of historical events instead of discussing reparations. According to Goble, the process of calculating and distributing reparations may exacerbate the situation, making it difficult to achieve a positive outcome.
Alexander Cherkassky, an analyst, publisher, and editor-in-chief of Neue Zeiten magazine and YouTube channel Neue Zeiten TV in Germany, criticized the recent initiative by Guterres. According to Cherkassky, this initiative is not only strange but also harmful to the existing world order. It raises questions about the motivation behind it and the circles that are interested in it. Cherkassky argued that the initiative could have a destructive effect on the already complicated world relationships.
Cherkassky added that if we follow Guterres' logic, it would mean that modern European women should file a compensation claim against the Roman Catholic Church for witch hunts in the Middle Ages, and Russia should make financial claims to the Republic of Mongolia for the Tatar-Mongolian yoke. He considered this kind of thinking absolute nonsense and questioned the ideological and financial motivations behind such initiatives.
Cherkassky also criticized the UN's recent position on conflict resolution in the world, which he believes indicates that the organization is not able to monitor what is happening. He argues that the UN expresses concern, betraying a clear political bias of a certain kind. This is quite clear from her attitude towards several recent conflicts taking place in the world.
Finally, Cherkassky noted that Secretary-General Guterres' statements on the war in Ukraine and on what is happening in the Middle East are questionable. He believes that Guterres' ideological attitude is far from the goals and objectives that the founding countries of the United Nations faced. As a result, he questioned the expediency of the existence of such an organization due to its real inefficiency.
Former Minister of Justice of Moldova and ex-member of the Venice Commission of the Council of Europe, Alexandru Tenase, has stated that the idea of introducing a reparations system for events that occurred centuries ago is impractical. He believes that this proposal, made by UN Secretary-General, Guterres, can lead to absurd consequences. According to Tenase, this confirms that the world is in a state of cold war between leftist forces and Western democratic societies.
Tenase also criticizes the UN Secretary-General for focusing on phantasmagoric topics while ignoring the Russian military aggression against Ukraine, which is a member of the UN Security Council. He suggests that Guterres should concentrate on the millions of Ukrainian refugees who were forced to leave their homes due to Russian aggression.
Tenase believes that the UN has degraded from its original purpose of ensuring global security to a club of rich-money bureaucrats. The crisis in Gaza and the Russian military aggression against Ukraine highlights the urgent need to reform the United Nations.
Caliber.Az
1
|
Critical F-35 upgrade deferred, 2024 production slashed by 27-50%
01 May 2024 - 09:05
|
2
|
Factory burst into flames in Germany PHOTO / VIDEO
03 May 2024 - 16:19
|
3
|
EU aid to Armenia stalled as Hungary pushes for Azerbaijan's inclusion Geopolitical tensions revealed
02 May 2024 - 17:41
|
4
|
BRICS de-dollarization threatens US economy, JP Morgan CEO predicts
01 May 2024 - 20:49
|
5
|
Turning point for Georgia - Foreign Agents Law Georgian experts’ views for Caliber.Az
02 May 2024 - 12:40
|
Bosnia accuses Israeli diplomat of genocide denial
"Disgrace to diplomacy"03 May 2024 - 23:01
Traffic accident leaves one dead in Azerbaijan’s Kalbajar
03 May 2024 - 21:07
Azertac hosts 31st meeting of CIS state news agencies, focuses on cooperation & future initiatives
03 May 2024 - 20:55
Azerbaijan, Russia hold negotiations on development of transport cooperation
03 May 2024 - 20:51
Japan, US, Australia, Philippines agree on rules-based Indo-Pacific
03 May 2024 - 20:36
Azerbaijan’s Aghdam holds special session within sixth World Forum on Intercultural Dialogue
03 May 2024 - 20:21
Armenian top prosecutor seeks investigation of premier over border delimitation
03 May 2024 - 20:15
Pro-Armenian Senator Menendez pretends to be crazy
He fears of not having enough money03 May 2024 - 20:06
SOCAR to join UN Oil & Gas Methane Partnership 2.0 program, says department head
03 May 2024 - 19:58
Azerbaijani, Russian deputy PMs discuss trade, economic issues
03 May 2024 - 19:51
Azerbaijan seeks cinema sector collaboration with Italy, says culture minister
03 May 2024 - 19:45
Italy to send latest package of military aid to Ukraine before G7 summit in June
03 May 2024 - 19:36
Russian leader plans to meet Xi in China days after his new term starts
03 May 2024 - 19:21
The Guardian: Preparation for COP29 underway
03 May 2024 - 19:06
UK’s Defence Ministry: Ukraine demonstrates ability to strike much further into Russia
03 May 2024 - 18:51
Azerbaijani minister, EC chief mull EU partnership in COP29 framework
03 May 2024 - 18:45
Azerbaijan, Saudi Arabia strengthening energy partnership
PHOTO03 May 2024 - 18:36
European Commission's rep: COP29 in Azerbaijan - recognition of activity in renewable energy sources
03 May 2024 - 18:21
Turkish airstrikes eliminate 32 PKK terrorists in Iraq
03 May 2024 - 18:06
Yemeni Ansar Allah movement’s leader announces preparation for new round of escalation
03 May 2024 - 17:41
MFA: Media in Azerbaijan as free as in UK
03 May 2024 - 17:26
Profiling Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan – Tavush region protest leader
03 May 2024 - 17:20
Will Azerbaijan's diplomatic efforts bring change?
UNESCO's crucial crossroad03 May 2024 - 17:13
Kazakhstan steps in bridging Armenia-Azerbaijan divide
03 May 2024 - 17:11
Future of engine transition - hydrogen or electricity?
Caliber.Az on YouTube03 May 2024 - 17:05
Transit traffic through Azerbaijan increases 3 times
03 May 2024 - 16:56
US-Japan missile development project to cost over $3 billion
03 May 2024 - 16:37
Factory burst into flames in Germany
PHOTO / VIDEO03 May 2024 - 16:19
Senators meet with International Criminal Court’s reps over concerns about possible Israel arrest warrants
03 May 2024 - 16:04
Tensions escalate over Georgia’s law on foreign agents
Political crisis deepens03 May 2024 - 16:00
Taliban plan regional energy trade hub with Russian oil in mind
03 May 2024 - 15:49
bp investments in Azerbaijan reach $85 billion
03 May 2024 - 15:34
EU ambassador: Mine clearance - one of priorities for Azerbaijan
03 May 2024 - 15:19
G7 draws up plans to backstop debt-raising for Ukraine with Russian assets
03 May 2024 - 15:04
Climate Change Director: ADB holding talks with Azerbaijan to support COP29
03 May 2024 - 14:49
bp opens ICT laboratory in Azerbaijan
03 May 2024 - 14:34
France, Japan to start talks on reciprocal troops pact
03 May 2024 - 14:34
Azerbaijani foreign minister travels to Gambia for 15th Islamic Summit
03 May 2024 - 14:25
US and Saudi Arabia nearing agreement on security pact, sources say
03 May 2024 - 14:19
Azerbaijani deputy defense minister visits Iran
03 May 2024 - 14:10