What's behind India's strategic neutrality on Russia's invasion of Ukraine

    WORLD  30 March 2023 - 12:13

    Countries in Africa, Asia, and the Middle East have all avoided taking sides on Russia's invasion of Ukraine -- but India's size and power make it the most influential nation to remain neutral, a year into the war.

    The world's second-largest country and the sixth-largest economy will continue to maintain ties to both Russia and the West with a posture of "strategic ambivalence," experts say, resisting a U.S. push to directly oppose Moscow while calling for "peace" and cooperation on what "common ground" there is, ABC News reports.

    Indian officials echoed that at this year's Group of 20 foreign ministers meeting in New Delhi, which ended earlier this month.

    "The G20 has the capacity to build consensus and deliver concrete results. We should not allow issues that we cannot resolve together to come in the way of those we can," Prime Minister Narendra Modi said in a video message at the gathering. "As you meet in the land of Gandhi and the Buddha, I pray that you will draw inspiration from India's civilizational ethos -- to focus not on what divides us, but on what unites us."

    Later, India's external affairs minister, Subrahmanyam Jaishankar, alluded to the divisions over the war.

    "There were issues and I think the issues, I would say, very frankly, concerned the Ukraine conflict on which there were divergences," Jaishankar said.

    Western leaders have been disappointed in India's reluctance to condemn Russian aggression, but they know India's reliance on Russian energy and weapons, paired with past problems with the U.S., present the country with a tempting option for neutrality, said Sahar Khan, a research fellow at the libertarian Cato Institute's Defense and Foreign Policy Department.

    At the same time, India is working to diversify its military supply, which is one of its major links to Russia and has been sending humanitarian aid to Kyiv.

    Rick Russow, a senior adviser and chair in U.S.-India policy studies at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a think tank, said that India is one of the only countries amid the war in Ukraine that is able to "pick up the phone and talk to leadership in both the United States and Russia on the same day."

    Western officials have been looking to India to explicitly condemn Russian President Vladimir Putin through this global platform, but they have been met with disappointment.

    India has long signaled its ambivalence - decrying the fighting but, for example, declining to participate in U.N. resolutions against Russia.

    Jaishankar said in October that "we have been very clearly against the conflict in Ukraine. We believe that this conflict does not serve the interests of anybody. Neither the participants nor indeed of the international community."

    At the G20 foreign ministers' meeting this month, Prime Minister Modi's message also conveyed his government's insistence on highlighting domestic issues - and India's top priorities - pertaining to the Global South, a category of countries in Asia, Africa and Latin America with similar socioeconomic characteristics.

    The multi-day meeting included sessions on food security, development cooperation and terrorism, among other topics.

    But the topic of Ukraine was unavoidable. Russia and China were the only states who refused to condemn the war, and India maintained its call for a peaceful solution without backing a specific country.

    Even before it was selected to host the G20, India had positioned itself as an impartial party to the war.

    In September, External Affairs Ministry spokesperson Arindam Bagchi said that India was supportive of the territorial integrity of both Ukraine and Russia.

    "India has repeatedly emphasized on the immediate cessation of hostilities and the need to resolve the ongoing conflict through dialogue and diplomacy. India's position has also been clear and consistent in so far as respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity of the countries concerned," Bagchi said then.

    Since Russia's attack on Ukraine began, the U.S has put pressure on India to take a stance, with President Joe Biden acknowledging early in the conflict that India's position on joining anti-Russia efforts was "shaky." And in May, Biden appeared to reference the countries' split on Ukraine during a meeting with Modi and others when he said, "This is more than just a European issue. It's a global issue."

    Despite that lack of alignment, the U.S. and India have still maintained a solid partnership in matters of commerce, technology, security and education.

    PHOTO: Secretary of State Antony Blinken meets with Indian External Affairs Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar on the sideline of the G20 foreign ministers' meeting in New Delhi on March 2, 2023.

    Why India has relied on Russia

    While India seems impartial to the Ukrainian-Russian conflict, especially in its reluctance to condemn Putin, it is acting on a history of reliance on Russia and past sidelining by the West, according to Harsh Pant, vice president of studies and foreign policy at the Observer Research Foundation, an Indian think tank.

    In 1998, in response to a series of nuclear weapons tests India conducted near neighboring Pakistan, countries including the U.S. imposed sanctions, leaving India unable to trade in high-end technology or, in the view of Indian officials, defend themselves against Pakistan -- with whom there is a history of sectarian conflict.

    Instead, at the time, India found defensive support from post-Cold War Russia, based on a relationship that stretched back to the Soviet Union.

    Pant said that much of India's weaponry has for years been manufactured by the Russians, who have also supplied India with energy.

    "If you look at India's big platforms like aircraft carriers, and nuclear submarines, they are all of the Soviet vintage, because the Soviet Union was willing to share technology with India," he said.

    Russia remains a major supplier of weapons to India and Russian equipment still makes up a large portion of the Indian Armed Forces' force, experts said. And India's dependence on Russian defense materials has been crucial for the country amid a protracted border dispute with China.

    India's declining dependence on Russia

    But recently, India has attempted to diversify its supply of weapons and develop its own defense industry, resulting in declining Russian arms deliveries to India.

    Pant said India previously acquired approximately 80% of its weapons from Russia. That number has dropped down to about 55%.

    "It's quite a serious decline in the share of Russian equipment, as it gets diversified to the West," Pant said, noting India has started to buy defense weaponry from the U.S. and Australia, two other countries in the so-called "Quad" that also includes Japan.

    That has led to some distance in India and Russia's relationship. Such relationships "don't really change overnight," Pant said. Rather, multiple factors can add up to major changes.

    "India and Russia have been drifting apart gradually and that is something that I think needs to be brought out: With or without the Ukraine war, India-Russia relations have been going in a negative direction," Pant said.

    The country is updating its defense industry, making it less manpower-heavy and more technology-heavy. Against the backdrop of China-India tensions, Russia's position as China's emerging partner has also made it harder for Russia to preserve its partnership with India.

    "China is already threatening India from multiple sides. If Russia also joins the bandwagon, then I think there is a problem. There is going to be a big issue for India, given its defense relationship, given its security environment and given the mismatch between Indians' and Chinese military capabilities," Pant said.

    Russow, with the Center for Strategic and International Studies, also said that though India is definitely more involved with Russia, the country believes its future lies closer to Western powers.

    "Things are working out for India," said Khan, at the Cato Institute. "They're getting some criticism, but they're fine."


    Subscribe to our Telegram channel

Read also

Europe considers reopening Afghan embassies, assessing Taliban recognition

16 July 2024 - 12:24

Yemeni armed forces target crude oil tankers in Red Sea, Mediterranean operations

16 July 2024 - 12:12

India summons Ukrainian ambassador over President Zelenskyy's remarks

16 July 2024 - 11:00

Netanyahu asserts Israel's intent to maintain control of Philadelphia Corridor

16 July 2024 - 10:00

Orban pushes for EU-Russia diplomatic revival In a letter to Charles Michel

16 July 2024 - 12:00

Donald Trump becomes official Republican presidential nominee

16 July 2024 - 09:26
Latest news

    Europe considers reopening Afghan embassies, assessing Taliban recognition

    16 July 2024 - 12:24

    Yemeni armed forces target crude oil tankers in Red Sea, Mediterranean operations

    16 July 2024 - 12:12

    Orban pushes for EU-Russia diplomatic revival

    In a letter to Charles Michel

    16 July 2024 - 12:00

    Pashinyan's vain hopes and growing Western crisis

    Armenia's challenges ahead

    16 July 2024 - 11:48

    Türkiye welcomes reopening of Azerbaijani embassy in Iran

    16 July 2024 - 11:36

    Russia downs 13 Ukrainian drones over various regions

    16 July 2024 - 11:24

    Israel admits tank shortage amid Gaza operations

    16 July 2024 - 11:12

    India summons Ukrainian ambassador over President Zelenskyy's remarks

    16 July 2024 - 11:00

    Armenian PM to attend European Political Community Summit

    16 July 2024 - 10:48

    China to receive Hamas, Fatah reps to reconcile rival Palestinian factions

    16 July 2024 - 10:36

    Yerevan's cynical attempt to whitewash ethnic cleansing

    Bill "On National Minorities"

    16 July 2024 - 10:24

    European Commission president cancels visit to Hungary

    16 July 2024 - 10:12

    Netanyahu asserts Israel's intent to maintain control of Philadelphia Corridor

    16 July 2024 - 10:00

    UK's new Labour government eyes closer ties with Azerbaijan

    Expert insight

    16 July 2024 - 09:48

    Azerbaijani Embassy in Iran reopens after long closure


    16 July 2024 - 09:37

    Donald Trump becomes official Republican presidential nominee

    16 July 2024 - 09:26

    US State Department hails progress in Azerbaijan-Armenia peace talks

    16 July 2024 - 09:15

    Lebanese sentiment divided as Israel-Hezbollah conflict risks escalation

    16 July 2024 - 09:04

    Russia's Middle East strategy: Exploiting instability

    16 July 2024 - 07:08

    Trump’s potential return spurs South Korea’s nuclear debate

    16 July 2024 - 05:12

    Emerging markets thrive amid US-China decoupling

    16 July 2024 - 03:10

    Joint military exercise in Belarus fuels EU anxiety over China’s intentions

    16 July 2024 - 01:05

    Iran's election exposes regime's fragility

    Illusion of reform

    15 July 2024 - 23:02

    Syria open to normalizing relations with Turkey, insists on adherence to int’l law

    15 July 2024 - 21:05

    France extends curfew in New Caledonia amid ongoing unrest

    15 July 2024 - 20:49

    Azerbaijan gears up for COP29 with NGO-driven initiatives

    15 July 2024 - 20:48

    Azerbaijani minister discusses strategic partnership with WB regional director


    15 July 2024 - 20:35

    Italy's public debt nears record high

    15 July 2024 - 20:20

    Russian president’s special envoy highlights COP29 preparation in Azerbaijan

    15 July 2024 - 20:05

    Azerbaijan to launch COP29 Initiative Grant Competition for NGOs

    15 July 2024 - 19:50

    King Charles III sends private letter to Trump

    15 July 2024 - 19:50

    WB to approve new partnership strategy with Azerbaijan for 2025-2029

    15 July 2024 - 19:40

    India urges Russia to expedite S-400 deliveries amid geopolitical tensions

    15 July 2024 - 19:35

    Azerbaijan unveils progress in demining operations in liberated lands

    15 July 2024 - 19:20

    Will the assassination attempt on Trump change America?

    Security takes a back seat in US

    15 July 2024 - 19:10

    Armenia, US launch joint military exercise Eagle Partner 2024


    15 July 2024 - 19:05

    Azerbaijan, Israel explore opportunities to strengthen economic & trade ties

    15 July 2024 - 18:55

    Azerbaijan poised to deepen tourism cooperation with Russia

    15 July 2024 - 18:40

    Azerbaijan honours martyrs on Türkiye's Democracy and National Unity Day

    15 July 2024 - 18:35

    Modi's controversial Moscow trip: Miscalculated diplomacy?

    Caliber.Az on YouTube

    15 July 2024 - 18:33

All news