The existential question about Putin’s mercenary boss
Opinion by Andreas Kluth
REGION 03 June 2023 - 02:00
In his piece for Bloomberg, Andreas Kluth wonders why Putin still tolerates the existence of Wagner Group's leader Prigozhin in spite of his accusations against Russia's top military brass.
Yevgeny Prigozhin shouldn’t have said “grandfather.” But it slipped out. That was last month, during one of his vulgar and lurid rants against the Russian top brass. Prigozhin, the leader of the Wagner Group, a private Russian military company, was posing in warrior gear as a Slavic Rambo, straddling the corpses of his fallen comrades and spitting expletives into the camera.
He was demanding ammo from the Russian army for his Wagner mercenaries, so he could finish the bloody siege for the Ukrainian city of Bakhmut. He blasted Russia’s overall war strategy. And then, apparently carried away by rage, he heaped scorn on a “happy grandfather” who “thinks he is good.”
Up to that point, his Russian audience assumed that Prigozhin was, as part of his megalomaniacal shtick, only railing against Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu and top generals. But the “grandfather” sounded an awful lot like Vladimir Putin, Russia’s president and de facto Tsar. Challenge or threaten Putin, and you’re done.
And yet, Prigozhin is still around. Having claimed victory over the rubble of Bakhmut, he seems to be regrouping his Wagner mercenaries. And Putin seems to tolerate his existence. Why?
Andrei Soldatov and Irina Borogan at the Center for European Policy Analysis in Washington, DC, believe that Putin wants to keep Prigozhin in the wings as a counterbalance against something he, Putin, fears even more than an uppity mercenary: the Russian army.
In his early years in power, the argument goes, Putin struggled to assert control over the brass. And as a former KGB man who thinks only in potential threats, he now worries that as his war against Ukraine drags on, a military putsch becomes more likely. Good, therefore, to have Prigozhin around to embarrass the army and keep them in line.
I ran that thesis by Andras Racz, a Hungarian scholar at the German Council on Foreign Relations in Berlin. Racz has long been studying the Wagner Group, and private military contractors generally (including America’s Academi, formerly known as Blackwater). He reads the situation differently.
First, Putin isn’t as worried about the loyalty of his own army as Soldatov and Borogan imply, Racz thinks. So Putin doesn’t need to maintain a counterbalance, and in any case doesn’t view Prigozhin as one. Nor does Putin fear Prigozhin, who has no support in the Russian elite. The president instead grows or prunes the Wagner boss’s stature as needed. And lately, he’s been clipping. One way he did that is with a new policy on hiring prisoners.
Starting last fall, Prigozhin, himself an inmate in his youth, went into prisons and recruited convicts for the frontline, about 50,000 in total. He cynically used those men as cannon fodder, in Bakhmut and elsewhere. This was a big help to Putin, because it outsourced death. Given a choice between sacrificing regular conscripts and prisoners-turned-mercenaries, Putin preferred the latter.
In February, however, Putin, trying hard to avoid another unpopular mass mobilization, prohibited Prigozhin from recruiting more prisoners. Now the Russian army hires them directly. So Putin has in effect throttled the supply of Wagner troops just as he may or may not have withheld ammunition.
Prigozhin remains completely dependent on Putin, and both men know it.
The other reason Putin doesn’t fear Prigozhin is the mercenary’s motivation.
Prigozhin actually wants to get his men out of Ukraine, which represents a loss leader for him. He instead needs them in lucrative places like the Middle East and Africa, where Wagner hawks its violence services to any warlord who asks. In return, Wagner gets the rights to exploit local resources — such as oil in Syria, diamonds or rare earths in Africa.
Putin likes these Wagner operations for their side effects. By spreading mayhem and unbearable human misery in regions like the Sahel, Wagner also causes mass migration to the European Union, which Prigozhin and Putin want to destabilize.
The real question, Racz thinks, is therefore not whether Prigozhin will ever challenge Putin for power — he won’t — or whether Putin is thinking of eliminating Prigozhin — he isn’t. It’s whether Wagner as an outfit is now damaged goods and must be replaced by another group.
One reason why countries outsource some warfare to the private sector is plausible deniability. The soldiers of fortune do the state’s bidding, but the government can claim it’s not responsible. For Wagner, however, that veneer of separation from the state is now gone. The whole world knows that Wagner is an extension of Putin’s regime.
The larger tragedy in these developments is the spreading role of mercenaries in modern warfare generally.
For much of history, mercenary war, which has been called the second-oldest profession, was the norm. It was soldiers of fortune who fought for Carthage in antiquity and Florence during the Renaissance, and who raped and pillaged in central Europe during the Thirty Years War. But then, with the rise of nationalism, states monopolized warfare for a century or so.
Since World War II, and especially since the Cold War, that trend has reversed again. And Russia is far from the only culprit. America used contractors almost as enthusiastically in Iraq and Afghanistan, as do drug cartels, warlords, extremists and insurgents elsewhere.
War is always hell, but wars waged by mercenaries — which the protocols to the Geneva Convention in 1977 tried to ban — are often more so. In “The Prince,” Machiavelli described mercenaries as “disunited, ambitious, without discipline, unfaithful; gallant among friends, vile among enemies; no fear of God, no faith with men.” He could have been thinking of Prigozhin — or any of the evil men who’d be happy to replace him.
Caliber.Az
1
|
Armenia's former defence minister raises concerns over faulty Indian weapons
18 March 2024 - 13:59
|
2
|
Netanyahu's future, Armenia's arms race and common foes of Azerbaijan and Israel Caliber.Az talks to Peter Lukimson
16 March 2024 - 12:27
|
3
|
France: A country that pays tribute to terrorism Turkophobic "Nemesis" hero honoured in Marseille
16 March 2024 - 14:50
|
4
|
UN supports Azerbaijan’s initiatives in combating mine threat
16 March 2024 - 14:34
|
5
|
NATO's strategic dance in the South Caucasus Balancing act for Baku & Moscow
18 March 2024 - 11:25
|
Ukrainian drone strikes destroy Russian oil refining capacity, says Gunvor CEO
19 March 2024 - 13:55
Türkiye reiterates its commitment to fighting terrorism in Iraq
19 March 2024 - 13:45
Defence giant ASELSAN unveils revolutionary solution for Turkish Navy
VIDEO19 March 2024 - 13:34
EU agrees to sanction 30 Russians over Alexei Navalny's death
19 March 2024 - 13:22
What's on the agenda of Xi Jinping's visit to France?
19 March 2024 - 13:11
Armenia, NATO mull relations between Baku, Yerevan
19 March 2024 - 13:10
Trump says Prince Harry could be deported from US over drug use
19 March 2024 - 13:01
Armenian MP calls 4 villages Azerbaijani settlements
They do not belong to us19 March 2024 - 12:58
How COP29 can drive investments in renewables to shape a sustainable future?
Ecologist assessment19 March 2024 - 12:50
President Biden pushes for ceasefire in talks with Israeli PM Netanyahu
19 March 2024 - 12:39
NATO Secretary General arrives in Yerevan
19 March 2024 - 12:28
Blinken in Manila as South China Sea tensions rise
19 March 2024 - 12:17
To have peace, Europe must prepare for war, EU council president says
19 March 2024 - 12:06
Azerbaijan continues to rid Khankendi of Armenian-left weapons
19 March 2024 - 11:54
EU foreign ministers reiterate support for Armenia
19 March 2024 - 11:44
The Sun: Princess Catherine spotted in public for first time in three months
19 March 2024 - 11:33
Armenian PM calls for diplomatic approach in border dispute with Azerbaijan
Address to Tavush residents19 March 2024 - 11:23
Israel strikes military targets near Damascus - Syrian MoD
19 March 2024 - 11:12
American journalist: NATO's Stoltenberg not antagonistic to Baku's interests
19 March 2024 - 11:01
EU looks forward to working with Azerbaijan to ensure success of COP29
19 March 2024 - 10:51
Russia destroys Ukrainian drones over Belgorod, Voronezh regions
19 March 2024 - 10:40
US crude oil exports hit record high in 2023
19 March 2024 - 10:29
Azerbaijani community protests UK Parliament's hearing on Armenians' resettlement from Karabakh
19 March 2024 - 10:19
South Korean defence chief says North Korea sent 7,000 munitions containers to Russia
19 March 2024 - 10:08
Most Armenian banks to stop accepting Russian Mir cards
19 March 2024 - 09:57
Armenian leading party wants to grant unlimited rights, arrest ban to EU observers
19 March 2024 - 09:46
Poland, Germany announce plans for joint rapid reaction force
Including "armoured coalition" for Ukraine19 March 2024 - 09:35
Jens Stoltenberg: NATO, Azerbaijan nearing agreement on new partnership framework
19 March 2024 - 09:24
Pashinyan says demarcating border with Azerbaijan enters practical phase
19 March 2024 - 09:14
EU - Egypt strategic partnership and implications for North Africa
Money for stability19 March 2024 - 09:00
Georgia's breakaway region is "discussing" becoming part of Russia
19 March 2024 - 08:46
Kremlin: The only way to protect Russia is to create a buffer zone with Ukraine
19 March 2024 - 07:15
EU Reporter: The EU’s “Strategy for Central Asia” lacks sincerity
19 March 2024 - 05:44
Iran parliament and Assembly of Experts' elections
Hardliners on the rise19 March 2024 - 04:01
South Korea hosted summit warns of AI risks to democracy
19 March 2024 - 02:26
Newsweek: Drone attack on helicopter in Moldova raises questions
19 March 2024 - 01:00
Iran inks big deals to develop six oil fields
18 March 2024 - 23:44
NATO boss backs Azerbaijan-Armenia peace talks during Baku visit
18 March 2024 - 22:15
EU to boost military support fund for Ukraine by 5 bln euros
Hungarian FM says18 March 2024 - 21:15
Azerbaijan, Iraq discuss economic cooperation
18 March 2024 - 21:05