How weapons firms influence the Ukraine debate
Analysis by Ben Freeman
WORLD 03 June 2023 - 22:01
When you hear a think tank scholar comment on the Ukraine war, chances are you’re hearing from someone whose employer is funded by those who profit from war, but you’ll probably never know it, Ben Freeman claims in his recent analysis for Responsible Statecraft.
“To be brutal about it, we need to see masses of Russians fleeing, deserting, shooting their officers, taken captive, or dead. The Russian defeat must be an unmistakably big, bloody shambles. …To that end, with the utmost urgency, the West should give everything that Ukraine could possibly use,” argues Eliot Cohen in The Atlantic.
What neither Cohen, who also famously pushed for the U.S. invasion of Iraq, nor The Atlantic acknowledge in the article is that most of the weapons Cohen mentions in the article — including long-range missiles, F-16s, and even F-35s — are made by funders of Cohen’s employer, the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS).
While this might seem like a glaring conflict of interest that, at the very least, should be disclosed in the article, a new Quincy Institute brief that I authored, “Defense Contractor Funded Think Tanks Dominate Ukraine Debate,” shows that this article isn’t an exception; it’s the norm. America’s top foreign policy think tanks are awash in funding from the defense industry. They’ve dominated the media market related to the Ukraine war, and they seldom, if ever, disclose that many of the weapons they’re recommending the U.S. give to Ukraine are made by their funders.
In short, when you hear a think tank scholar comment on the Ukraine war, chances are you’re hearing from someone whose employer is funded by those who profit from war, but you’ll probably never know it. That’s because 78 percent of the top-ranked foreign policy think tanks in the U.S. receive funding from the Pentagon or its contractors, as documented in the new brief.
At the very top, defense industry influence is even greater: every single one of the top 10 ranked foreign policy think tanks receives funding from the defense sector. And, for many think tanks, the amount of defense funding is enormous. For example, CSIS, the Center for a New American Security (CNAS), and The Atlantic Council all reported receiving more than a million dollars a year from the defense sector.
These and other think tanks that receive considerable defense sector funding have publicly advocated for more militarized U.S. responses to the Ukraine war and, compared to their counterparts at think tanks that accept little or no defense sector funding, have dominated the media landscape related to the Ukraine war.
The new brief analyzed mentions of these top ranked foreign policy think tanks in Ukraine war related articles that appeared in The New York Times, The Washington Post, and The Wall Street Journal. This analysis revealed that media outlets were more than seven times as likely to cite a think tank with defense sector support as they were to cite a think tank without it. Of the 1,247 think tank media mentions we tracked for the brief, 1,064 (or 85 percent) were mentions of think tanks with defense sector funding. And, the two most mentioned think tanks in Ukraine war related articles were think tanks flooded with defense sector dollars: CSIS and The Atlantic Council.
Yet, we only know the extent of CSIS and the Atlantic Council’s funding from the defense sector because both think tanks are commendably transparent about their donors and list all funders, within funding ranges, on their websites. Unfortunately, many of the nation’s top think tanks aren’t as forthcoming. In fact, the new brief found that nearly one third of the top U.S. foreign policy think tanks do not publicly disclose their donors. This included some of the most mentioned think tanks in media articles about the Ukraine war, like the American Enterprise Institute (AEI). Though AEI scholars have disclosed at public events that the organization receives funding from defense contractors, the organization does not list its donors on its website.
Media outlets were, similarly, not transparent about the conflicts of interest of the experts they were citing. In fact, none of the media mentions analyzed in the brief were accompanied by disclosures of defense industry funding of think tanks that were, at times, recommending policies that could financially benefit their funders.
All of this points to several clear recommendations for reform.
First, Congress should mandate that think tanks disclose their funders. Given think tanks’ prominent role in the policymaking process and the enormous amounts of money they receive from the defense industry, foreign governments, and other special interests, it’s imperative that the public and policymakers know who is funding the think tank expert they’re hearing from.
Second, media outlets should report any potential conflicts of interest with sources they’re citing about major U.S. foreign policy decisions. As the brief notes, “By not providing this information media outlets are deceiving their readers, listeners, or viewers.”
Given the growing chorus of research documenting how think tank funding influences think tank work, the very least media outlets can do is let their readers know when a source might be biased, especially when they’re commenting on questions of war and peace.
Caliber.Az
1
|
20 points. What did Armenia, the EU and the US agree on in Brussels? Sensational details on Caliber.Az
17 April 2024 - 11:01
|
2
|
Iran seeks international backing following missile strikes on Israel Raisi calls Russia & Qatari leaders amid tension
17 April 2024 - 16:56
|
3
|
Serbian President seeks Azerbaijani support amid Western pressures Insights from Political Scientist Stevan Gajić
17 April 2024 - 13:10
|
4
|
French ambassador recalled from Azerbaijan amidst bilateral strain Macron admits defeat
17 April 2024 - 15:19
|
5
|
Is Ukraine on the edge? Big vulnerabilities
17 April 2024 - 16:13
|
Turkish Foreign Ministry on Azerbaijan-Armenia deal
20 April 2024 - 17:09
Berlin climate dialogue to discuss Azerbaijan's COP29 preparations
20 April 2024 - 16:49
Triumph of sovereignty: Azerbaijan's quiet victory in the withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers
Has & Verdiyan on Caliber.Az20 April 2024 - 16:30
Armenia's anti-corruption efforts under scrutiny
GRECO report highlights gaps20 April 2024 - 16:21
Azerbaijani foreign minister meets outgoing Iranian ambassador
Affirms strengthening bilateral ties20 April 2024 - 16:12
Türkiye ‘neutralizes’ 5 PKK/YPG terrorists in northern Syria
20 April 2024 - 15:55
IMF affirms readiness to support Azerbaijan in hosting COP29
20 April 2024 - 15:37
Ukrainian parliamentary delegation to visit Azerbaijan
20 April 2024 - 15:19
Armenia, Azerbaijan reach historic agreement at negotiating table
Prime Minister says20 April 2024 - 15:09
NATO trying to push Russia out of South Caucasus - analyst
20 April 2024 - 14:50
Azerbaijan, World Bank keen to cooperate on green transition
20 April 2024 - 14:31
Armenian PM announces withdrawal of Russian border guards from Tavush
20 April 2024 - 14:23
Athens conf highlights destruction by Armenia of cemeteries in Azerbaijani territories
20 April 2024 - 14:13
Media resources of Armenia, several other countries spread fakes
Statement by Azerbaijan Media Development Agency20 April 2024 - 14:05
Israeli strike on Iranian air defense radar site limited in scope
20 April 2024 - 13:54
Azerbaijani defense minister meets commanders of Land Forces
PHOTO/VIDEO20 April 2024 - 13:45
Azerbaijan, UN discuss transition to green energy
20 April 2024 - 13:39
Russian analyst: EU mission in Armenia turns into NATO mission
20 April 2024 - 13:23
US House advances $95 billion Ukraine-Israel package toward Saturday vote
20 April 2024 - 13:04
Unveiling Armenia’s motives behind lawsuits at The Hague
From politics to policy20 April 2024 - 12:35
Foes Azerbaijan and Armenia agree 'historic' return of villages
20 April 2024 - 12:28
Police seize cache of weapons & ammunition in Khankendi
Interior Ministry figures20 April 2024 - 12:06
Pro-Armenian senator urges US to cut military aid to Azerbaijan
French MP questions US diplomatic response20 April 2024 - 11:47
Azerbaijan engages with IEA to forge energy efficiency roadmap
20 April 2024 - 11:28
Ukraine targets Russia’s seven regions in drone attacks
20 April 2024 - 11:09
Explosion hits military base in Iraq's Babil
20 April 2024 - 10:49
Armenian PM shares insights on Brussels meeting with party members
20 April 2024 - 10:35
UN chief urges Baku, Yerevan to resolve outstanding issues
To normalize relations20 April 2024 - 10:21
US hails return of four villages of Gazakh district
20 April 2024 - 10:00
Western Azerbaijani Community condemns G7 for discrimination in refugee rights call
20 April 2024 - 09:49
Azerbaijan’s Gazakh District hails liberation of villages with joyful demo
PHOTO20 April 2024 - 09:37
EU endorses Azerbaijani-Armenian negotiations, backs delimitation process
20 April 2024 - 09:31
Azerbaijan showcases diplomatic valor by hosting COP29
20 April 2024 - 09:13
Ethiopia opens door for prized coffee exports to foreigners
20 April 2024 - 09:02
Saudi Arabia's $500 billion Neom megacity reportedly seeking new sources of cash
20 April 2024 - 07:03
Ukraine’s frontline is collapsing – and Britain may soon be at war
20 April 2024 - 05:04
Can TikTok's owner afford to lose its killer app?
20 April 2024 - 03:05
Sydney bishop forgives alleged attacker and urges followers not to retaliate
20 April 2024 - 01:03
US blocks Palestine from becoming UN full member
19 April 2024 - 23:00
Egypt, Türkiye to discuss bilateral trade, regional issues, including Gaza
19 April 2024 - 20:59