Russia's army: An overestimated power in the war against Ukraine
    Analysis by Deutsche Welle

    REGION  29 September 2022 - 23:30

    Deutsche Welle has published an article saying that "at the outset of the invasion of Ukraine, Russian President Vladimir Putin believed in a quick victory that did not come to pass. How strong is Russia's army really?" Caliber.Az reprints the article.

    After the fall of the Soviet Union, Moscow did everything it could to maintain its status as a superpower — including as a permanent member of the UN Security Council. When it became clear that Russia could not claim a right to the spot as an economic power, it instead defined its greatness in military terms.

    Over the decades, Russia's army has been touted as one of the strongest in the world. Indeed, a nuclear-armed military. As if to remind the world of this fact, President Vladimir Putin has regularly treated both Russians and the world to perfectly choreographed parades and military exercises.

    How powerful an army really is, however, cannot be demonstrated by goose-stepping on the Red Square, but on the battlefield. Now, the Russians are being shown up by a much smaller army in Ukraine. How can that be?

    How big is Putin's army?

    On paper, the Russian armed forces claim to have 1 million soldiers, and in the near future 1.1 million, according to Margarete Klein of the German Institute for International and Security Affairs. But the real size is much smaller, she told DW.

    A large number of the deployable Russian units have already been used in Ukraine, she said. "They have suffered major losses in terms of soldiers killed or injured."

    Exact casualty numbers are difficult to determine, but US intelligence believes Russia has suffered at least tens of thousands of dead and wounded.

    The idea that Russia has infinite reserves of deployable soldiers is a far cry from reality, said George Barros of the Institute for the Study of War, a US think tank. He added that the course the war has taken so far proves that the world has long overestimated the strength of the Russian army. The goal, he said, of Putin's recent partial mobilization push is only to maintain the current front line after all the losses.

    Sent to the front without training or equipment

    The state of Russia's military strength can also be illustrated by the groups of people currently being drafted. "There are men there who are over 50 years old and have health problems," Barros said. This observation has been backed up by numerous stories and videos posted to social media.

    Reservists need to be trained and equipped before they deploy to war, Barros explained. However, many will now receive only one or two months of training, which is far from enough. Others are even being sent to the front lines without any training or equipment, he said, adding that the only thing these conditions are likely to accomplish is increasing the casualty numbers.

    According to US-based Russian security expert Pavel Luzin, Ukraine will never abandon the fight, even as Putin's henchman carries out sham referendums in the east of the country. Furthermore, he said, Russia's arms industry is not in a position to provide significant amounts of supplies in the short-term, certainly not for those currently being drafted. Margarete Klein added that they are now using old weapons and bullets that have been in storage since Soviet times.

    Then again it is unclear how many of these stored weapons have already been sold as a result of corruption, or if they are even in working order anymore. The Russian arms industry lacks the necessary microchips for high-precision weapons and other spare parts, Klein said.

    The only advantage Russia has really is a greater population at its disposal to draft into the military. However, as Barros pointed out, an army needs more than soldiers to be successful. It needs modern weapons, good training, leadership, motivation, and logistical planning.

    "Simply putting more men on the front lines is not going to solve the problem the Russians have," the defence expert said. The well-trained and well-equipped mercenaries have also not had the desired impact, Barros added.

    Intimidating the West with talk of nuclear weapons

    Experts agree that using the spectre of nuclear weapons is meant to intimidate the West. "This threat is not new," said Klein. The goal, she said, is to undermine the West's support for Ukraine. Militarily, the use of nuclear weapons would achieve nothing. They could have some use politically, but Klein believes that their deployment is unlikely given that it would almost certainly lose Russia the support of key allies China and India.

    However, other experts, such as Ted Galen Carpenter of the Cato Institute in Washington, point out that "if Putin is faced with the choice of either using nuclear weapons or having to answer for his crimes in an international court, he will choose the nuclear option."

    Carpenter said that Putin still wants to end the conflict quickly, and that if Ukraine and the West showed a willingness to negotiate, Moscow would probably come to the table.

    On the other hand, Klein, Barros, and Luzin all agreed that the war will only really come to an end if the West either abandons Ukraine or Putin suffers a total defeat.

    Caliber.Az




Read also

Minister: Türkiye to hold ground operation in Syria as soon as possible

26 November 2022 - 14:58

Kazakh president announces Senate election date

26 November 2022 - 16:23

Armenia's Security Council secretary to visit France and Germany

26 November 2022 - 12:22

Turkish Kızılelma-TB3-TCG Anadolu to be exemplary for whole world Western media analytics

26 November 2022 - 12:01

Swedish PM Kristersson pledges to meet Türkiye's demands

26 November 2022 - 11:24

Russia drafts decree banning oil sales to price cap participants

26 November 2022 - 10:46
ADVERTS
Latest news

    Malawi's vice president arrested on corruption charges

    27 November 2022 - 03:05

    Xi tells Kim China wants to work with North Korea for peace: KCNA

    27 November 2022 - 02:04

    Ukraine to send grain to starving African countries for free

    27 November 2022 - 01:01

    Macron to raise US subsidies in talks with Biden next week

    27 November 2022 - 00:02

    China reports record-high new daily coronavirus cases for third straight day

    26 November 2022 - 23:00

    US bans Huawei, ZTE equipment sales citing national security risk

    26 November 2022 - 22:00

    NYT: US set up Ukrainian artillery repair facility in Poland

    26 November 2022 - 21:00

    World Cup: Neymar, Danilo out of Brazil’s next match due to ankle injury

    26 November 2022 - 20:00

    The Times: Small nuclear power plants in UK to replace gas in quest for net zero

    26 November 2022 - 19:00

    Pakistani PM expresses gratitude to Azerbaijani President

    26 November 2022 - 18:02

    Cuban president hails excellent ties between Havana, Beijing

    26 November 2022 - 17:44

    Azerbaijani President signs order on conscription for military service

    26 November 2022 - 17:34

    Venezuelan delegation arrives in Mexico for talks with opposition

    26 November 2022 - 17:25

    President Aliyev approves laws on establishment of Azerbaijani embassies in several countries

    Including Israel

    26 November 2022 - 17:05

    Minister: Italian authorities should ask EU for delay in imposing embargo on Russian oil

    26 November 2022 - 17:02

    President’s special rep: Azerbaijan may implement projects in five spheres in East Zangazur, Karabakh

    26 November 2022 - 16:43

    Kazakh president announces Senate election date

    26 November 2022 - 16:23

    President: Efforts of destroying Ukraine with hunger, now with darkness, cold - futile

    26 November 2022 - 16:05

    Azerbaijani FM, EU special rep discuss efforts to normalise ties with Armenia

    26 November 2022 - 15:47

    Azerbaijanis living in Europe protest against putting anti-Azerbaijani resolution for vote

    26 November 2022 - 15:31

    Azerbaijan strengthening potential of Middle Corridor

    Review by Caliber.Az

    26 November 2022 - 15:15

    Minister: Türkiye to hold ground operation in Syria as soon as possible

    26 November 2022 - 14:58

    Azerbaijani, Russian leaders discuss trilateral agreements on Karabakh

    26 November 2022 - 14:52

    Azerbaijan’s positions undergo fire from armed Armenian groups

    26 November 2022 - 14:47

    Israel shares intelligence dossiers on Iranian arms exports to Russia

    26 November 2022 - 14:41

    Participants of conference on geopolitics and security of Middle Corridor visit Aghdam

    26 November 2022 - 14:27

    President Aliyev's son Heydar ties knot

    PHOTO

    26 November 2022 - 14:20

    Polish PM arrives in Kyiv

    PHOTO

    26 November 2022 - 14:10

    Geneva hosts conference on challenges of landmines in Azerbaijan

    26 November 2022 - 13:47

    Ambassador of Ukraine thanks Azerbaijani people for support

    26 November 2022 - 13:32

    UK intel: Russia removing nuclear warheads from ageing missiles, firing unarmed munitions at Ukraine

    26 November 2022 - 13:13

    Azerbaijan intercepts UAV of illegal Armenian armed groups

    Defence Ministry's statement; PHOTO

    26 November 2022 - 13:10

    WSJ: Fearing sabotage, Europe patrols pipelines with mine hunters and unmanned subs

    26 November 2022 - 12:56

    VP: Azerbaijan, Türkiye support normalisation of ties with Armenia

    26 November 2022 - 12:36

    Armenia's Security Council secretary to visit France and Germany

    26 November 2022 - 12:22

    Turkish Kızılelma-TB3-TCG Anadolu to be exemplary for whole world

    Western media analytics

    26 November 2022 - 12:01

    ISW: Reports of poorly staffed Russian mobilised personnel dividing Russian information space

    26 November 2022 - 11:42

    Azerbaijani Defence Ministry refutes Armenia’s disinformation

    26 November 2022 - 11:28

    Swedish PM Kristersson pledges to meet Türkiye's demands

    26 November 2022 - 11:24

    Turkish FM hails work to supply Azerbaijani gas to South-Eastern European countries

    26 November 2022 - 11:02

    Russia drafts decree banning oil sales to price cap participants

    26 November 2022 - 10:46

    Assistant to Azerbaijani first VP visits Mexico

    PHOTO

    26 November 2022 - 10:25

    "We stand by brotherly Armed Forces of Türkiye in the fierce fight against terrorism"

    Defence Minister Zakir Hasanov offers condolences to his Turkish counterpart

    26 November 2022 - 10:05

    Inauguration ceremony of Kassym-Jomart Tokayev begins in Kazakhstan

    26 November 2022 - 09:59

    President Aliyev: If you have strong army, good allies then you can feel yourself on safe side

    PHOTO/VIDEO/UPDATED

    26 November 2022 - 09:50

All news