How realistic are Russian reparation payments to Ukraine?

    WORLD  27 November 2022 - 07:55

    The UN General Assembly has adopted a resolution calling on Russia to pay reparations to Ukraine for the destruction caused by its war of aggression. But it is not binding. Can Russia be held liable, Marina Baranovskaya wonders in her article for DW?

    Caliber.Az reprints the article.

    There does not yet seem to be an end in sight to the war in Ukraine. But the international community is already discussing how Russia might be forced to pay for the damage caused by its army. On November 14, a UN General Assembly resolution calling on Moscow to pay reparations received 94 votes in favor. Fourteen states voted against the resolution, and 73 abstained.

    In September, Ukrainian Prime Minister Denys Shmyhal estimated the direct physical damage as a result of the war so far at $326 billion (€318 billion). He told a meeting in Brussels that World Bank experts had verified the sum, which was likely to have increased by the end of the war. Russia has already rejected the resolution. Russian Ambassador to the UN Vasily Nebenzya said that the document was "legally null and void."

    Reparation payments in history

    Reparations are effectively compensation payments made by a state for damage it has caused with its criminal actions. International institutions or a post-war peace treaty determine the sums and the nature of the payments, explained international law expert Paul Gragl of the University of Graz in Austria.

    One of the best-known cases of reparations concerned the German Reich after its defeat in World War I in 1918. The Treaty of Versailles required the payment of more than 200 billion gold marks over decades. The last transfer was made by the Federal Republic of Germany, the legal successor to the German Reich, in 2010. Germany also had to pay reparations to the Allies after World War II.

    How Russia could be forced to pay

    UN General Assembly resolutions are not legally binding. It's more a case of political weight because the resolutions reflect the opinion of the international community, Gragl argued — "a political intention aimed at not letting it be forgotten that Russia is obliged, as the aggressor, to make up for these damages."

    Paula Rhein-Fischer also spoke of a political signal. Russia was unlikely to be persuaded to pay reparations by existing international mechanisms, she said. "At the United Nations International Court of Justice [whose decisions are legally binding (Editor's note)] there is a jurisdictional problem. It has jurisdiction only if both states have agreed to become parties to the case. The court is already hearing Ukraine's case against Russia for violation of the Genocide Convention, but compensation will be limited in this case.”

    A legally binding decision on reparations could, therefore, be made by the International Criminal Court in The Hague (ICC). "It is entrusted with convicting individuals of genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and the crime of aggression, although the ICC cannot prosecute the crime of aggression committed by Russian decision-makers. This is because in this case prosecution of this crime would require a UN Security Council resolution, which Russia, as a permanent member of the Security Council, would veto. Therefore, the establishment of a special tribunal is under discussion," said Rhein-Fischer.

    In theory, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) could obligate Russia to pay reparations, she continued. However, since Russia left the Council of Europe it is no longer subject to ECHR rulings and has not been a party to the European Convention of Human Rights since September 2022. Thus, the court could only require Russia to compensate Ukraine for the destruction caused from February to September 2022.

    Past experience has shown Russia is not likely to implement a ECHR ruling, Rhein-Fischer said, adding that it was "highly disputed" whether the European Convention on Human Rights is even applicable to ongoing conflicts. "For the time being, it seems unlikely that the Russian Federation will pay reparations in the near future."

    Frozen Russian assets as compensation?

    Discussions are underway as to whether Russian funds frozen as part of the sanctions imposed on Moscow could be used to pay reparations. For the most part, this would apply to foreign assets of sanctioned Russian companies, the property of private individuals, and foreign exchange reserves of the Russian Central Bank.

    "There is a legal difference between freezing assets and confiscating assets," said Gragl, pointing out that freezing is only temporary. Seizing Russian assets as reparations needs a legal basis, explained Rhein-Fischer. There is no international arbitration commission yet, however, and a decision on seizure by national courts involves major legal complications.

    The UN resolution approved on November 14 provides for the establishment of a new international mechanism that could help. Ukraine's Deputy Justice Minister Iryna Mudra said it could enable numerous states to move from "discussions to action."

    Immunity protects state assets for sovereign purposes — which arguably includes Russia's foreign exchange reserves — from seizure under international law, Rhein-Fischer pointed out. However, the General Assembly resolution might provide the opportunity to include a provision in treaties between Ukraine and third parties that would strip Russia of this immunity.

    Third parties, peace treaty

    "In my opinion, that point raises legal questions, because contracts cannot be concluded to the detriment of third parties," said Paula Rhein-Fischer. In this case, Russia would be the third party not involved in the contract. "Another question is whether this practice could lead to changes in already existing rules of customary international law."

    From a legal point of view, according to the expert, it would be less problematic to lift sanctions against Russia in return for the country's agreement to reparations payments. A peace treaty between parties, where Russia agrees to compensate the damage it has caused would be ideal. "Unfortunately, that is unlikely in the current situation."


    Subscribe to our Telegram channel

Read also

Blinken tours China to promote some ties

25 April 2024 - 13:26

Media: China harbours ship tied to North Korea-Russia arms transfers

25 April 2024 - 13:11

Official: Hamas would lay down its weapons if two-state solution implemented

25 April 2024 - 13:54

Israeli Air Force strikes dozens of targets in Gaza VIDEO

25 April 2024 - 12:43

CENTCOM: US repells Houthi attacks on ships

25 April 2024 - 11:44

EU's proposed Russia sanctions to target oil tankers, ships carrying N. Korean equipment

25 April 2024 - 11:16
Latest news

    Port of Baku: the Eurasian trade hub working to expand and accelerate growth

    Article by Euronews / VIDEO

    25 April 2024 - 15:39

    Hybrid warfare being waged against Armenia, official says

    25 April 2024 - 15:24

    Azerbaijani police discover cache of weapons in Khankendi, linked to Armenian forces

    25 April 2024 - 14:58

    Zakharova slams Armenian media for distorting Russian leadership’s statements on Baku-Yerevan ties

    25 April 2024 - 14:44

    Baku, Budapest cement economic ties, sign protocol

    25 April 2024 - 14:27

    Yerevan ready to discuss gas purchase with Baku – Armenian Speaker


    25 April 2024 - 14:15

    Azerbaijan set to take bold steps vis-à-vis climate change - minister

    25 April 2024 - 14:09

    Official: Hamas would lay down its weapons if two-state solution implemented

    25 April 2024 - 13:54

    Türkiye captures nearly 3,000 Islamic State suspects in 10 months


    25 April 2024 - 13:40

    Blinken tours China to promote some ties

    25 April 2024 - 13:26

    Azerbaijani presidential aide showcases Fuzuli's rebirth in stirring social media video

    25 April 2024 - 13:15

    Media: China harbours ship tied to North Korea-Russia arms transfers

    25 April 2024 - 13:11

    Western Azerbaijan Community condemns US human rights report as discriminatory

    25 April 2024 - 12:58

    Israeli Air Force strikes dozens of targets in Gaza


    25 April 2024 - 12:43

    Hungary prepares to participate in Karabakh's reconstruction

    25 April 2024 - 12:29

    Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan appoints new prime minister

    25 April 2024 - 12:15

    Political analyst: Good relations with Türkiye to be favourable for Armenia

    25 April 2024 - 12:13

    Iran re-evaluating its ties with Azerbaijan, Armenia

    Baku - more important, honest partner than Yerevan

    25 April 2024 - 12:00

    Balancing Turkmenistan – Afghanistan relations

    Deviated approach

    25 April 2024 - 11:48

    CENTCOM: US repells Houthi attacks on ships

    25 April 2024 - 11:44

    France proposes new EU sanctions to fight Russian disinformation

    25 April 2024 - 11:31

    Minister: Cooperation with Azerbaijan contributes to Hungary's energy security

    25 April 2024 - 11:20

    EU's proposed Russia sanctions to target oil tankers, ships carrying N. Korean equipment

    25 April 2024 - 11:16

    Azerbaijani Army conducts command-staff exercises to maintain combat readiness


    25 April 2024 - 11:10

    Armenian politician slams recent burning of Azerbaijani, Turkish flags in Yerevan

    Calling the action belligerent pity

    25 April 2024 - 11:04

    Azerbaijan-Kyrgyzstan business priorities: Advancing trade, energy, transport initiatives

    Review by Caliber.Az

    25 April 2024 - 10:51

    Media: US sends long-range ATACMS missiles to Ukraine

    25 April 2024 - 10:38

    Georgia's pre-election turmoil

    How the Law on Foreign Agents shapes voter sentiment?

    25 April 2024 - 10:27

    India stands for closer cooperation in fight against terrorism at BRICS meeting

    25 April 2024 - 10:25

    Iranian president urges international courts to punish Israel for Gaza Strip operation

    25 April 2024 - 10:09

    Azerbaijan submits report on Convention Against Torture to UN

    25 April 2024 - 09:55

    Azerbaijan, Kyrgyzstan sign Memorandum on Cooperation in religious sphere

    25 April 2024 - 09:43

    US welcomes start of Azerbaijan-Armenia border delimitation process

    25 April 2024 - 09:21

    PM vows to boost UK defence spending to 2.5% of GDP by 2030

    25 April 2024 - 09:07

    Azerbaijani, Turkish communities hold rally against fictitious Armenian genocide in Washington


    25 April 2024 - 09:00

    EU’s 2050 net zero goals at risk as electric vehicle rollout faces setbacks

    25 April 2024 - 07:03

    World’s largest wealth fund issues inflation warning on hot commodity markets

    real wildcard

    25 April 2024 - 05:04

    How US F-16 fighter jets stack up to Su-35s sent to Iran?

    25 April 2024 - 03:05

    Belgian brewer whose body produces its own alcohol cleared of drink driving

    25 April 2024 - 01:03

    Milan becomes latest European hotspot to battle overtourism

    No ice cream and pizza after midnight

    24 April 2024 - 23:00

All news