Politics of Ukrainian reconstruction
WORLD 01 December 2022 - 15:16
US newspaper The Hill has published an analysis of the post-war construction plans in Ukraine. Howard Shatz, a senior economist at the nonprofit, nonpartisan RAND Corporation and professor of policy analysis at the Pardee RAND Graduate School, Khrystyna Holynska, an assistant policy researcher at RAND, visiting professor at the Kyiv School of Economics and William Courtney, an adjunct senior fellow at RAND, who served as US ambassador to Kazakhstan and Georgia, contributed to the analysis. Caliber.Az reprints the article.
When fighting subsides, Ukraine may undergo reconstruction on the scale of the post-World War II Marshall Plan. Debate is ramping up about core issues, such as the scope of reconstruction, sources of funding and reforms needed for success. Ukraine and the West might begin now to forge a consensus on these issues.
Scope of reconstruction. Divergencies in investment priorities may be wide. As of September 5, the respected Kyiv School of Economics assessed damage to infrastructure to be $114.5 billion. On September 9, the World Bank, European Commission and Ukraine estimated the cost of reconstruction and recovery to be $349 billion. On October 24, Ukrainian Prime Minister Denys Shmyhal put the cost of post-war national reconstruction at nearly $750 billion.
German Chancellor Olaf Scholtz and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen have urged a “new Marshall Plan” to construct residences, schools, roads, bridges and other infrastructure. By comparison, the Marshall Plan was less grandiose, contributing $150-160 billion in today’s dollars to 16 countries. It sought to spur agricultural and industrial production and trade and restore sound finances.
In Ukraine, high priority may be accorded to restoring electricity and other public utilities, rebuilding transportation and other infrastructure, and renovating industry, agriculture and services. Ukraine has had one of Europe’s most wasteful economies; reconstruction will give higher priority to conservation.
The West might give early attention to defining a scope for reconstruction that can gain broad support. Expectations in Ukraine might be high. In Congress, some on both sides of the aisle may seek to limit Ukraine aid.
Sources of funding. No one wants punitive reparations of the kind that embittered post-World War I Germany and abetted the rise of Adolf Hitler. The Treaty of Versailles demanded that Germany pay $269 billion in today’s dollars, leading economist John Maynard Keynes to predict its economic collapse and wider chaos.
There may be a way out. Some $300 billion in Russian Central Bank assets held in the West could be used for reconstruction without reducing Russia’s output or employment. Access to forfeited Russian assets could make possible some of the more ambitious options for Ukraine’s reconstruction. For this purpose, European Council President Charles Michel has called it “extremely important” to confiscate Russian assets. Overcoming sovereign immunity might be legally complex but feasible.
There is precedent for forfeiture. In 2003, the United Nations Security Council required all UN members to freeze and transfer assets of the former Iraqi regime to the new Development Fund for Iraq. Recently the UN General Assembly approved a resolution calling for Russia to pay war reparations. The vote was 94 in favour, 14 against and 73 abstaining. The use of Russian assets may be popular in the West and seen as just recompense. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy calls the creation of such a mechanism a part of “international legal reality”.
To the extent Western donors contribute to reconstruction funding, the US may look to the European Union and its member states to shoulder most of the burden. The US and UK have provided over four-fifths of Western military aid to Ukraine, and this may continue. Europeans seem aware. They have taken the lead in donor conferences this year at Lugano, Switzerland, and in Berlin, Germany. EU leadership is logical since Ukraine now has candidate status for membership.
Reforms. As waste in Afghanistan and Iraq showed, reconstruction may fail if donors lack coherent strategies or projects that are not sustainable or are prone to corruption. Donors have long worried about corruption in Ukraine. It ranks in the bottom third of Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index.
Ukraine has made progress. It operates a transparent online platform for public procurement and government e-services. Oversight by independent media and civil society in Ukraine has proven valuable. Corruption ought not impede private investment. Donor conditionalities – much as the Marshall Plan had – might provide an incentive for Ukraine to deepen reforms as it reimagines its future.
The EU emphasizes that Ukraine should have the “highest rule-of-law standards and … effective anti-corruption authorities.” Congress may mandate robust oversight by inspectors general and regular spending reports. To sustain donor confidence, Ukraine may see benefit in Western conditions.
The West and Ukraine might develop early and clear standards and a coordinated venue for reconstruction planning. Aid expectations in Ukraine are high. Delays or disruptions could undermine popular support for reforms.
The West and Ukraine have some distance to go to develop strategies and consensus for reconstruction. The West could continue to demonstrate its support for Ukraine’s defence of its land and people by preparing now for post-war reconstruction.
Caliber.Az
1
|
20 points. What did Armenia, the EU and the US agree on in Brussels? Sensational details on Caliber.Az
17 April 2024 - 11:01
|
2
|
Times: UK, Armenia hold talks on sending illegal migrants to Armenia
15 April 2024 - 10:00
|
3
|
"Historical" Armenia vs. present-day Armenia Unveiling the conundrum
15 April 2024 - 09:11
|
4
|
Caliber.Az to reveal sensational details of "Brussels meeting" Important announcement
16 April 2024 - 12:09
|
5
|
Iran seeks international backing following missile strikes on Israel Raisi calls Russia & Qatari leaders amid tension
17 April 2024 - 16:56
|
Want to move to Europe?
17 April 2024 - 23:00
IDF strikes Hezbollah military facilities in Lebanon
17 April 2024 - 21:18
Georgian PM accuses country’s President of being an “agent of foreign influence”
In rebuke on transparency bill17 April 2024 - 21:15
Azerbaijan to showcase climate change adaptation at COP29
FAO official says17 April 2024 - 21:10
Swiss parliament wants ban on extremist symbols
17 April 2024 - 20:58
Protest rally against foreign agents bill resumes in Tbilisi
17 April 2024 - 20:50
UK urges European countries to increase defence spending
17 April 2024 - 20:45
AZAL, DFS aviation services forge key partnership to equip Lachin airport
17 April 2024 - 20:33
Turkish FM, Hamas leader discuss Gaza aid, cease-fire
17 April 2024 - 20:20
Russian peacekeepers' mission in Karabakh accomplished
Member of State Duma says17 April 2024 - 20:08
Tackling 10 prejudices about hydrogen following Clean Transition Dialogues
17 April 2024 - 20:00
Azerbaijani Ombudswoman raises mine issue in liberated territories at meeting with UNDP rep
17 April 2024 - 19:53
Azerbaijan, Tatarstan forge stronger ties across trade, innovation, humanitarian endeavors
17 April 2024 - 19:40
Azerbaijani FM, CICMA executive director engage on chairmanship priorities & collaboration
17 April 2024 - 19:32
Azerbaijan plans Europe-bound exports of green hydrogen made in "recently liberated territories"
Article by Hydrogen Insight17 April 2024 - 19:28
UK PM Sunak plans to create "smoke-free generation" with tough measures on tobacco
17 April 2024 - 19:13
Azerbaijan and Albania announce visa-free regime
Legislative progress underway17 April 2024 - 18:59
Azerbaijan, Tatarstan discuss developmental directions of economic partnership
17 April 2024 - 18:46
OSCE Chair-in-Office due in Azerbaijan
17 April 2024 - 18:30
Armenia's economy lacks development
Expert highlights concerns17 April 2024 - 18:15
Azerbaijan's Air Force, Air Defence Forces conduct tactical exercises in Nakhchivan
Video, Photo footage from drills17 April 2024 - 18:01
UN continues support for Azerbaijan's demining efforts in Karabakh region
17 April 2024 - 17:48
Azerbaijani president designates Shusha as 2024 Youth Capital of OIC
Action plan underway17 April 2024 - 17:35
Czech Republic collects 500,000 shells for Ukraine
17 April 2024 - 17:23
President: Iran’s operation shatters Israeli military’s invincibility myth
17 April 2024 - 17:10
Iran seeks international backing following missile strikes on Israel
Raisi calls Russia & Qatari leaders amid tension17 April 2024 - 16:56
Georgian parliament approves draft law on foreign agents
17 April 2024 - 16:41
Azerbaijan, Israel discuss energy cooperation
17 April 2024 - 16:27
Is Ukraine on the edge?
Big vulnerabilities17 April 2024 - 16:13
Azerbaijan, Pakistan discuss defence cooperation
17 April 2024 - 15:59
United States enhances support for Armenia
17 April 2024 - 15:45
EU interested in Azerbaijan's development of Middle Corridor
PHOTO17 April 2024 - 15:31
President Aliyev, Kairat Sarybay discuss COP29, green transport concept
17 April 2024 - 15:27
President’s aide confirms Russian peacekeepers’ withdrawal from Azerbaijan
The process has already started!17 April 2024 - 15:19
French ambassador recalled from Azerbaijan amidst bilateral strain
Macron admits defeat17 April 2024 - 15:19
Hereditary Azerbaijanophobe in Armenia and his provocations
17 April 2024 - 15:04
US, Iraq discuss Iraq-Türkiye oil pipeline
17 April 2024 - 14:50
Türkiye "neutralizes" 4 PKK/YPG terrorists in northern Syria
17 April 2024 - 14:35
Pro-Armenian Senator Menendez throws the blame for bribery case on his wife
17 April 2024 - 14:26
Kremlin confirms withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Karabakh
17 April 2024 - 14:19