The true purpose of Ukraine’s counteroffensive
Analysis by The Atlantic
WORLD 10 June 2023 - 09:01
What does it all mean? That the Ukrainian counteroffensive has begun.
This counteroffensive will also look different from the D-Day movies because Ukraine’s goals are not merely military. Yes, Ukrainian troops are probing Russian defenses up and down the 1,000-kilometer front line. Yes, the Ukrainians are conducting “shaping operations,” hitting ammunition dumps and other targets behind Russian lines. Yes, Ukraine wants to take back territory lost since February 2022, as well as territory lost in 2014. Yes, we know the Ukrainians can do it, because they’ve done it before. They fought the Russians out of northern Ukraine at the very beginning of the war. They recaptured Russian-held parts of the Kharkiv district in September, and the city of Kherson a couple of months later.
But in addition to taking back land, they are also conducting a sort of psychological shaping operation: They have to convince the Russian elite that the war was a mistake and that Russia can’t win it, not in the short term and not in the long term, either. Toward this end, they are also seeking to convince ordinary Russians that they aren’t as safe as they thought, that the war is nearer to their own homes than they believed, and that President Vladimir Putin isn’t as wise as they imagined. And the Ukrainians have to do all of this without a full-scale invasion of Russia, without occupying Moscow, and without a spectacular Russian surrender in Red Square.
The anti-Putin Russians fighting in Russia are part of that battle. This group, which seems to contain some authentic Russian extremists and some authentic opponents of Putin (but may also contain Ukrainians pretending to be Russian extremists or opponents of Putin), does have a military purpose. These incursions can help neutralize the immediate border zone, and draw Russian troops away from more important battles. The group’s leaders appear to have killed a senior Russian officer and are said to have taken prisoners.
But they, too, are part of a different game. As one of the group’s members (nickname “Caesar”) told The New York Times, they aim to provide “a demonstration to the people of Russia that it is possible to create resistance and fight against the Putin regime inside Russia.” By their very existence, they prove that apathy is not mandatory, that the Russian nation is not unified, and that no one is secure just because they live inside the borders of Russia.
The drones in Moscow could have the same effect. I don’t know who launched them—Ukrainian special forces, Russian saboteurs, or Ukrainian special forces pretending to be Russian saboteurs. But the effect is the same: They show Muscovites that no one is untouchable, not even the residents of the Kremlin. Maybe they won’t persuade people to “create resistance and fight against the Putin regime,” but they might help persuade people to start thinking about what comes next.
And indeed, some people are clearly thinking about what comes next. Although no evidence indicates that Yevgeny Prigozhin, the leader of the Wagner mercenaries, is actively trying to eliminate Putin, he does seem to be part of a competition to replace him, should the Russian president accidentally fall out a window. During an interview Monday, he mocked the luxurious life of Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu’s daughter, implied that Shoigu himself is lazy, and described the chief of the general staff throwing “paranoid tantrums, yelling and squealing at anyone surrounding him.” We are, he said, “two months away from the firing squads”—by which he meant the firing squads that will eliminate these degenerate leaders. One Russian officer who said he had been captured and interrogated by the Wagner Group issued a statement claiming that Prigozhin’s men were threatening and humiliating Russian soldiers. Prigozhin, in turn, says the regular Russian army opened fire on his mercenaries and left land mines to obstruct their movement.
In this context, the destruction not just of the big dam on the Dnipro River but of other dams and waterways all across occupied Ukraine has a clear purpose. Floods create chaos, forcing the Ukrainian state to care for evacuees. They put large, unexpected bodies of water between the Ukrainians and Russian forces, making it impossible to move equipment. These actions also send a psychological message: We will do anything—anything—to stop you. We don’t care how it looks. We don’t care who it damages.
Confirmed reports say that the Russian occupation regime is not rescuing people stranded on the roof of their house by the flood, and that the Russian army is shelling people engaged in rescue operations. Russian soldiers have also drowned, Ukrainian spokespeople believe. An army that was willing to waste tens of thousands of men in the pointless nine-month battle of Bakhmut is unlikely to care.
Remember that all of this—the weird psyops, the exploded dam, the Russian infighting—has unfolded even before anyone has reliably spotted the Western-trained, Western-equipped Ukrainian brigades that are meant to lead this counteroffensive. On Tuesday, the Russian Ministry of Defense announced with great fanfare that it had destroyed some of this equipment, including a German Leopard 2 tank. Hours later, Russian bloggers examined the video clips they produced. Alas, the objects destroyed seem to be not Leopard tanks but John Deere tractors. Future reports from the Russian ministry should be treated with caution.
Future reports from any source should be treated with caution. What we can see is not the “fog of war,” in the old-fashioned sense; instead it is a kind of swirling tornado, a maelstrom of claims and counterclaims, memes and countermemes, real battles taking place away from television screens and fake ones happening on camera. The Normandy landings were followed by a long, bloody Allied slog through France, which no one back home watched in real time. The certainty that D-Day was a true turning point emerged only in retrospect. This Ukrainian counteroffensive is, so far, disappointing fans of panoramic drama, set-piece battles, and heroic tales. Those might, or might not, come later. In the meantime, remember that the true purpose of the counteroffensive is not your entertainment.
Caliber.Az
1
|
20 points. What did Armenia, the EU and the US agree on in Brussels? Sensational details on Caliber.Az
17 April 2024 - 11:01
|
2
|
Caliber.Az to reveal sensational details of "Brussels meeting" Important announcement
16 April 2024 - 12:09
|
3
|
Iran seeks international backing following missile strikes on Israel Raisi calls Russia & Qatari leaders amid tension
17 April 2024 - 16:56
|
4
|
Serbian President seeks Azerbaijani support amid Western pressures Insights from Political Scientist Stevan Gajić
17 April 2024 - 13:10
|
5
|
French ambassador recalled from Azerbaijan amidst bilateral strain Macron admits defeat
17 April 2024 - 15:19
|
Two countries in Europe powered by 100% renewable energy as wind capacity soars
19 April 2024 - 03:05
Farewell to metals in industry forever
19 April 2024 - 01:03
Poland to join European Sky Shield scheme, following thaw with Berlin
18 April 2024 - 23:00
UN chief sees risk of full-scale conflict in Middle East
18 April 2024 - 21:16
Azerbaijan, Austria discuss areas of potential cooperation
PHOTO18 April 2024 - 21:04
Azerbaijan discusses partnership opportunities with CICA at COP29
PHOTO18 April 2024 - 20:53
Russian Army deploys new version of BM-27 Uragan MLRS Rocket Launcher in Ukraine
18 April 2024 - 20:40
Europe moves forward with major hydrogen projects
18 April 2024 - 20:27
US, Britain issue new sanctions on Iran in response to Tehran's attack on Israel
18 April 2024 - 20:13
Türkiye's Togg starts working on new B-SUV model
18 April 2024 - 19:59
US commends Azerbaijani deminers, pledges support for complete demining of lands
18 April 2024 - 19:46
Georgian opposition announces “full mobilization”
18 April 2024 - 19:32
Azerbaijan, Austria discuss implementation of joint industrial projects
18 April 2024 - 19:18
Israeli forces withdraw from area of Nuseirat refugee camp in central Gaza
18 April 2024 - 19:04
Azerbaijani parliament speaker: France eyes to continue colonialism policy in South Caucasus
18 April 2024 - 18:49
Iran warns it knows where Israel's nuclear sites
"Our hands - on trigger"18 April 2024 - 18:34
Congress Committee’s rep: New Caledonia expresses gratitude to Azerbaijan
18 April 2024 - 18:19
Historian: France trying to destroy culture of Kanak people
18 April 2024 - 18:04
Iran oil exports hit six-year high as West prepares sanctions
18 April 2024 - 17:49
Russia, Azerbaijan announce withdrawal of peacekeepers from Karabakh
Signaling a new phase in post-conflict dynamics18 April 2024 - 17:46
What to expect from Russia’s withdrawal from Karabakh?
Looking for new horizons18 April 2024 - 17:41
Baku Initiative Group: Azerbaijan fighting against colonialism, neo-colonialism
18 April 2024 - 17:34
Azerbaijan holding conference with New Caledonian Congress reps
18 April 2024 - 17:19
Lies and provocation of Iran's ambassador to Armenia
We have something to remind him18 April 2024 - 17:13
Miscalculation leads to escalation in clash between Israel, Iran
18 April 2024 - 17:04
EU's rep voices grave concerns over escalating tensions between Israel, Iran
18 April 2024 - 16:49
India kicks out Türkiye from Navy’s shipping project
18 April 2024 - 16:34
Azerbaijani ambassador: Armenia uses fake information as evidence in public court hearings
18 April 2024 - 16:19
Azerbaijani police officers find weapons, ammunition in Zangilan
PHOTO18 April 2024 - 16:04
Azerbaijani, New Caledonian parliaments sign memorandum of cooperation
18 April 2024 - 15:49
MFA: Russia exerts many efforts to resolve Azerbaijan-Armenia relations
18 April 2024 - 15:34
A blow-by-blow fact
Russian peacekeepers' mission accomplished18 April 2024 - 15:12
Azerbaijani energy minister invited to US for UN General Assembly discussions
18 April 2024 - 15:03
Baku Initiative Group facilitates Azerbaijan-New Caledonia cooperation
Congress chair applauds efforts18 April 2024 - 14:49
Azerbaijan to take steps to deal with Armenian vandalism at Khudavang Monastery
18 April 2024 - 14:35
"Green" ambitions: Azerbaijan's push for hydrogen production
Caliber.Az review18 April 2024 - 14:31
SpaceX launches 23 Starlink satellites from Florida
18 April 2024 - 14:21
Bashlibel tragedy survivors manage to break out of Armenian army siege only after 113 days
18 April 2024 - 14:16
Caliber.Az investigation raises dissatisfaction of US State Department
Facts are stubborn things18 April 2024 - 14:12
German police arrest two suspected of spying for Russia
18 April 2024 - 14:06