Belfast Agreement serves as model for Armenia-Azerbaijan peace talks
Drawing parallels
INTERVIEWS 11 June 2024 - 17:31
Vadim Mansurov Caliber.Az |
Former UK Ambassador to Azerbaijan, James Sharp, expressed his opinion on social network X (formerly Twitter), suggesting that Azerbaijan could reasonably demand Armenia to relinquish its territorial claims by amending the country's constitution. Sharp cited the example of Ireland in 1998, specifically referencing the amendment to the constitution as part of the Belfast Agreement.
In his turn, Farid Shafiyev, Chairman of the Center of Analysis of International Relations (AIR Center), expressed gratitude to the British diplomat for his perspective, noting the importance of such an approach in his response post.
The Belfast Agreement is a document on the political settlement of the conflict in Northern Ireland, concluded on April 10, 1998. The Irish Constitution was amended in relation to territorial claims to Northern Ireland, which is part of the United Kingdom.
In order to understand how the Belfast Agreement can help Yerevan give up its territorial claims to Azerbaijan, Caliber.Az correspondent turned to the AIR Center Chair Farid Shafiyev.
- Why did you consider the Belfast Agreement mentioned by the British diplomat to be extremely important as an analogy for resolving the disputes between Baku and Yerevan?
- Because it is the most universal as an example. At the moment, though, the biggest problem that the diplomat touched upon is Yerevan's opinion and its recent statement that the whole debate on amending the Armenian constitution is solely an internal matter of Armenia. Simply put - don't advise us, it is up to us to decide.
But Baku is worried for a reason: experience shows that any international agreement can be canceled by the country's Constitutional Court or its parliament - such cases have already happened in international practice. Therefore, this is a matter of both national and international law, not an internal Armenian affair, especially if we take into account that our countries are now working on a peace treaty.
By the way, at one time Robert Kocharian was elected president of Armenia despite the fact that he did not have a five-year residency requirement. To circumvent this condition, the Constitutional Court of Armenia counted his residence in Karabakh as “residence on the territory of Armenia”. Therefore, the issue of changing the Constitution of Armenia must be resolved at the highest level, and it is certainly impossible to limit ourselves to half measures.
- How can Azerbaijan use the precedent of the Belfast Agreement?
- The Belfast Agreement, also known as the Good Friday Agreement, is perhaps the most convincing precedent in this context. It was concluded relatively recently, in 1998, so it is a rather recent precedent from the European experience, which some of our partners, especially friends of Armenia, often like to refer to. Please, here is a real example from the very heart of Europe, where the Constitution of the Republic of Ireland, namely Articles 2 and 3, contained claims to Northern Ireland, which is a part of Great Britain. These contradictions led to years of bloody conflict, terrorist attacks by Irish separatists in Britain, one of which nearly killed British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher. But under the 1998 Belfast Agreement, Ireland promised to amend its constitution and recognize Britain's full sovereignty over Northern Ireland. This was eventually done, and the bloodshed in the region stopped.
- Don't you think that behind the referendum on changing the Constitution of Armenia there are serious concerns of Pashinyan, despite his obvious understanding of the importance of this issue? Will he be able to take such a step and how can Azerbaijan influence this process?
- Yes, some Armenian analysts agree on one thing: Pashinyan's situation is very difficult, and if he now goes to amend the country's constitution, it is fraught with negative consequences for him. Therefore, there are several other options - for example, a reference in the peace treaty to Armenia's obligations to change the constitution is likely. Armenians, for example, promise that there will be an article in the peace treaty stating that reference to domestic legislation cannot be the basis for non-compliance with the treaty. But this is also not enough.
There are many pitfalls here, and, for example, the Constitutional Court of Armenia may revoke the treaty in five to ten years. Therefore, the process should preferably be carried out before the signing of the peace treaty or there should be a clear timeline that, for example, a year after the signing of the peace treaty, the Armenian constitution should be amended.
But the latter approach is my personal assumption. And not going for any change of the constitution simply because, you see, it is dangerous for Pashinyan - this is not an argument. Such a passage, in fact, means that Armenia is not ready for peace. But it is not only us who need peace, all countries in the region need peace, and Azerbaijan is not taking the initiative unilaterally, otherwise there is no sense in it.
- Are we to believe that James Sharp's reaction and post suggest that the UK can provide us with some more separate diplomatic and political support, to influence behind the scenes the opinions of European countries or Yerevan's decision in this matter, to remove barriers to signing a peace treaty? Can we count on that?
-No, I do not think that Britain will show any eagerness and act as a mediator, here we are talking primarily about European experience in this issue. Especially since the bloody part of the conflict ended after the signing of the Belfast Agreement. In the future, after the signing of the peace treaty, it will be possible to use the experience of one or another European country in reconciling peoples.
But I can note that the AIR Center conducted training on this issue with the help of European partners. On the experience of Northern Ireland we studied the situation and the search for a solution, an expert from Great Britain took part in the event especially for this purpose. So the AIR Center can professionally assist in this matter.
Caliber.Az
1
|
Armenian special forces' bold move Confiscation sparks political backlash
24 June 2024 - 17:07
|
2
|
Armenia’s military build-up & western alignments risk renewed conflict Baku warns Yerevan
23 June 2024 - 11:39
|
3
|
Steering through tangled web of conflict & peace between Azerbaijan & Armenia High time to do away with a vicious circle
23 June 2024 - 09:17
|
4
|
Armenia's truce violations amid rising tensions & strategic weapons deals with France Those who ignore history are bound to repeat it
23 June 2024 - 15:31
|
5
|
Why does Russia want to recognize the Taliban government? Graveyard of empires
25 June 2024 - 12:36
|
Security chief: Armenia's future relations with Russia hinge on Moscow's position
26 June 2024 - 12:31
Presidential aide: Diplomacy without military strength akin to music without instruments
26 June 2024 - 12:17
President Aliyev receives Italian-made military transport aircraft C-27J Spartan
26 June 2024 - 12:04
Turkish authorities disrupt international drug cartel in Spain
26 June 2024 - 11:52
Azerbaijan's Air Force: Guardians of the nation's skies
PHOTO26 June 2024 - 11:40
Julian Assange pleads guilty for leaking America's national secrets
Banned from returning to US without permission26 June 2024 - 11:28
Armenia receives tenth package of proposals from Azerbaijan
26 June 2024 - 11:16
Israel accuses UN of keeping food at warehouses in Gaza
26 June 2024 - 11:04
German Bundeswehr set to secure massive munitions production contract
26 June 2024 - 10:53
Pentagon ex-advisor warns US of losing NATO ally
26 June 2024 - 10:40
Russian FM: BRICS to suspend admitting new members
26 June 2024 - 10:27
Former Swiss president elected Council of Europe chief
26 June 2024 - 10:15
Russia, Ukraine each return 90 prisoners of war
26 June 2024 - 10:02
Azerbaijan gains victory over Armenia in anti-terrorist operation rapidly, minister says
26 June 2024 - 09:50
SOCAR, Germany's VNG ink MoU for natural gas & renewable energy co-op
26 June 2024 - 09:38
Azerbaijan celebrates 106th anniversary of Armed Forces
26 June 2024 - 09:22
Azerbaijan confirms identities of 20 missing Individuals from First Karabakh War
26 June 2024 - 09:10
Climate crisis threatens West Africa's coastal cities
26 June 2024 - 09:03
Global green-energy transition faces critical challenges
26 June 2024 - 08:17
When will China have a sixth-gen fighter jet?
26 June 2024 - 06:13
China stands to gain significantly from Ukraine war
26 June 2024 - 04:10
Western economies urged to adapt to Chinese innovation in EV sector
26 June 2024 - 02:07
Macron's rightward shift backfires, bolstering far-right National Rally
26 June 2024 - 00:05
Iran’s new nuclear threat
Weaponizing threshold status25 June 2024 - 22:03
Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry congrats Slovenia on National Day
25 June 2024 - 21:14
Iranian presidential candidates discuss foreign policy in penultimate TV debate
25 June 2024 - 20:59
Baku hosts 11th consular consultations between Azerbaijani & Russian Foreign Ministries
25 June 2024 - 20:42
Iran reaffirms commitment to JCPOA, slams US & E3/EU non-compliance
25 June 2024 - 20:39
Azerbaijani foreign minister meets Russian envoy to discuss peace process with Armenia
25 June 2024 - 20:30
Federal cabinet approves national counter-terrorism plan amid opposition concerns
25 June 2024 - 20:22
Albanian parliamentary commission holds hearing for ambassador candidate to Azerbaijan
25 June 2024 - 20:08
Top official: Russia, Azerbaijan forge robust partnership
25 June 2024 - 19:30
ANAMA, EU delegation hold conference on combating mine threat
PHOTO25 June 2024 - 19:18
SOCAR, Equinor explore future collaboration
25 June 2024 - 19:06
Azerbaijan, IEA working on new nenewable energy, efficiency commitments
25 June 2024 - 18:54
Erdogan condemns Dagestan attacks in call with Putin
25 June 2024 - 18:42
Turkish, Armenian foreign ministers hold telephone conversation
25 June 2024 - 18:39
Israel’s top court rules ultra-Orthodox Jews must be drafted into military
25 June 2024 - 18:30
Estonian prime minister to become Europe's top diplomat
25 June 2024 - 18:16
Turkish FM contrasts BRICS, G7 in terms of scope and objectives
25 June 2024 - 18:04