World needs better blueprint for structural reform
Opinion by Financial Times
WORLD 05 March 2024 - 00:01
The Financial Times has published an opinion piece arguing that governments should be honest about the fact that liberalisation creates losers as well as winners. Caliber.Az reprints the article.
A perennial challenge for every country is ensuring that living standards rise over time, so that today’s adults deliver better opportunities for their children than they had. The key to rising living standards is improved productivity — more output from a given level of inputs. But there also exists a related challenge, to ensure that productivity gains are broadly shared: that growth is inclusive.
Economists who advise governments have a go-to toolbox of policies — structural reforms to liberalise trade, product and financial markets — that they recommend to deliver improved productivity. These reforms are often designed to give greater sway to market forces and free enterprise in the economy. Remarkably, however, this approach — variously referred to as the Washington consensus or neoliberalism — has been largely absent in the policies of recent US administrations.
In previous work, my colleagues and I documented a global plateauing of economic liberalisation since the 1990s. We perused national legal statutes and official websites to develop measures of structural reforms in product, labour and financial markets. This plateauing is a marked break from earlier decades, and is worrisome given the link between liberalisation and productivity, and the imperative of strong growth to support the green and demographic transitions.
To restore reform momentum, a dose of transparency is needed about what liberalisation can and cannot deliver. Some have noted that multilateral institutions, such as the IMF, are less inclined to push for reforms in their flagship publications, and infer that this reflects diminished enthusiasm for reform. This is not the case. Rather, it reflects a valid concern that reforms are unpopular among voters. The answer is not to pull one’s punches, however. It is, rather, greater forthrightness about the impact of reform.
First, reforms take time to work. Meaningful gains might only be visible in macroeconomic data over five to 10 years. Such a lag will create problems for governments that need to face voters in a shorter timeframe.
Second, the evidence suggests that the extent of the growth dividend differs across reforms. Lowering tariff and non-tariff barriers to trade, and boosting legal protection of property rights, really does deliver: economists’ faith in free trade and a strong court system is well-placed. The dividend from other reforms, such as labour market deregulation (for example, reducing the scope of collective bargaining) or eliminating regulations on cross-border capital movements, seems less robust.
Third, reforms work by spurring efficiency-boosting resource reallocations in response to relative price shifts. Inherent in such reallocations is that some will gain, while others will lose. Even a small minority of vocal losers can undermine reform, and lukewarm support from winners might not change the outcome. This makes politicians hesitant.
Fourth, reforms are not hard-wired to produce inclusive growth. In the data, it is evident that some reforms (for example, financial deregulation) engender an equity-efficiency trade-off, increasing growth and inequality. In such cases, inclusive growth is not the outcome.
Fifth, the electoral consequences of reform need to be incorporated into economists’ advice. In recent work, my colleagues and I examined how vote shares are affected by reforms implemented during a government’s term in office, controlling for a range of economic and political factors that influence electoral outcomes. The results underscore the importance of implementing reform early in the term to avoid an electoral backlash. This finding is related to the delayed growth dividend from reforms in the face of immediate distributional losses.
The electoral analysis also points to the importance of implementing reform during good economic times. It is difficult for voters to parse whether a downturn is due to reforms or to something else, and they may wrongly attribute a recession to reform when other factors were responsible. When times are good, moreover, it is much easier for workers made redundant in newly-unprofitable sectors to find a job elsewhere.
The evidence also suggests an electoral backlash for reforms that generate a significant growth-equity trade-off, ie, where inequality rises following reform.
Careful design of liberalisation packages is needed to ensure that losers from reform do not derail the agenda. Attention to timing with respect to the economic and political cycles is essential, as are adequate safety nets and trampoline policies to support bounceback for adversely-affected workers. When it comes to structural reform, politicians are right to ignore facile advice to “just do it”.
Caliber.Az
1
|
Phantom arms deal: How false claims aim to derail Baku-Tehran diplomacy Azerbaijan embraces "forewarned is forearmed" principle
25 July 2024 - 15:34
|
2
|
Could France’s anti-NATO rhetoric trigger domestic turmoil? Leftist Mélenchon's stance sparks historical echoes
24 July 2024 - 10:24
|
3
|
Azerbaijan: The new powerhouse of aluminium production amid global market strain "Green" era's requirement
25 July 2024 - 17:05
|
4
|
Brussels' bait and Yerevan's rush to swallow it The visa-free temptation
24 July 2024 - 09:00
|
5
|
West-backed Armenia likely to spark conflict with Azerbaijan rather than seek peace Caliber.Az reveals expert prognoses
25 July 2024 - 11:10
|
Japan addressing increasing incidents of customer harassment
Service culture under strain27 July 2024 - 03:05
Swiss spots struggle with social media-driven visitor impact
Tourism vs. nature27 July 2024 - 01:03
German chancellor tackles EU expansion, internal reform challenges
Path forward26 July 2024 - 23:03
Italian newspaper explores Azerbaijan's ancient Albanian churches
26 July 2024 - 21:08
Azerbaijani prosecutor general declares ties with Türkiye as strategic partnership
PHOTO26 July 2024 - 20:55
Azerbaijan, Italy strengthening military relations
PHOTO26 July 2024 - 20:42
China demands withdrawal of US nuclear weapons from Europe
26 July 2024 - 20:29
Pentagon concedes to spreading anti-Sinovac propaganda in Philippines
26 July 2024 - 20:16
COP29 presidency team hosts events to tackle key climate agenda issues
26 July 2024 - 20:03
Israel targets Türkiye’s TRT Haber team covering Al-Aqsa mosque incident
26 July 2024 - 19:51
COP20 president: Azerbaijan should lead with ambition at COP29
26 July 2024 - 19:38
Turkish defence minister, Azerbaijani ambassador discuss strengthening military ties
26 July 2024 - 19:25
FBI seeking to interview Trump as part of assassination attempt investigation
26 July 2024 - 19:12
US presidential candidate cites potential path to victory with Biden out of race
26 July 2024 - 18:58
Turkish MP confirms plans for official Azerbaijani school in Istanbul
26 July 2024 - 18:44
US vice president’s call for peace in Gaza sparks controversy with Israel
26 July 2024 - 18:30
FM: Italy to appoint ambassador to Syria after 10 years
26 July 2024 - 18:17
Head of Georgian Parliament blames opposition for compromising national safety
Aid to Ukraine at Georgia’s expense26 July 2024 - 18:03
South Caucasus on edge: West fuels Armenia's war drums
Yerevan clings to deceitful rhetoric26 July 2024 - 18:02
Media: Iran arms Hezbollah with advanced weapons
26 July 2024 - 17:49
Bolsonaro intends to run for Brazilian presidency in 2026, citing confidence in winning
26 July 2024 - 17:36
Armenian PM visits modernised Margara checkpoint on Turkish border
VIDEO26 July 2024 - 17:22
Boeing considers to convert its top fighter into an electronic warfare jet
Caliber.Az on YouTube26 July 2024 - 17:17
Belarus ready to expand cooperation with North Korea
26 July 2024 - 17:09
EU appoints new special representative for South Caucasus
26 July 2024 - 17:01
Azerbaijani-Chinese partnership defies "first among equals" attitudes
Rising above geopolitical cynicism26 July 2024 - 16:55
Armenia's militarization: A "peace agenda" with an armed approach
Yerevan must revisit recent historical lessons26 July 2024 - 16:42
Azerbaijan approves cooperation pacts with Türkiye, Kazakhstan
26 July 2024 - 16:33
Media: US informs Iran of readiness to return to nuclear deal
26 July 2024 - 16:29
Turkish forces take down PKK terrorists in coordinated Iraq and Syria raids
VIDEO26 July 2024 - 16:16
Israeli air strikes hit Hezbollah outposts in response to rocket fire
26 July 2024 - 16:03
Kremlin spox: EU ridicules Orban over Moscow visit
26 July 2024 - 15:51
Armenian parliamentary delegation visits Georgia to strengthen bilateral ties
26 July 2024 - 15:38
Washington talks peace while arming Yerevan
26 July 2024 - 15:38
Travellers from 13 nations explore rebuilding of Karabakh, East Zangazur
PHOTO26 July 2024 - 15:25
European Commission transfers €1.5 billion from frozen Russian assets to aid Ukraine's defence
26 July 2024 - 15:25
Trump says US to destroy Iran in case of his assassination
26 July 2024 - 15:12
Kremlin declares dialogue with West futile amid hostility toward Russia
26 July 2024 - 14:59
Somalia, Azerbaijan share common positions on many international forums
Minister’s statement26 July 2024 - 14:46
Azerbaijan promoting tourism potential in India
PHOTO26 July 2024 - 14:33