Politico: There is still place for neutrality in Ukraine

    WORLD  30 March 2023 - 08:02

    According to a piece by Politico, grievously wronged, Kyiv argues that this is no time for niceties, including impartiality. But for some organizations, it is crucial. Caliber.Az reprints the article.

    Speaking before the United States Congress 11 days after the terror attacks on New York and Washington in 2001, then President George W. Bush made clear it was time to choose. “Every nation, in every region, now has a decision to make. Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists.”

    From the perspective of an aggrieved nation, such a black-and-white ultimatum seemed reasonable — although less so when the war against al-Qaeda morphed into a US-led invasion of Iraq that didn’t have the approval of the United Nations. And that expansion of the war against terror goes some way to explaining why some Global South nations, troubled by Western double standards, are now reluctant to choose a side in Russia’s war on Ukraine.

    However, along with its Western partners, Ukraine — a grievously wronged nation — is now likewise arguing that this is no time for niceties, and to them, this includes neutrality. Yet, for some organizations, neutrality is exactly what’s required — otherwise, their raison d’être would be shattered, they wouldn’t be able to fulfil their missions and the world would be a much poorer place for it.

    “The closer you come to the front line, the more people know how important neutrality is because it protects you,” said veteran Swiss diplomat Mirjana Spoljaric, the first ever woman to head the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC). The ICRC currently has nearly a thousand workers in Ukraine, and “we have very little means of assuring safety and security for our staff other than our strict 160-year-old neutrality and impartiality,” she told POLITICO.

    “We are fulfilling our role in international armed conflict by relying on our established work modalities, by talking to all parties, by ensuring confidentiality, by insisting on being granted access to prisoners of war, and doing so through all appropriate and available communication channels that we have,” Spoljaric said.

    “If you ask us to criticize one party in public, communication channels and access will close. For me, the responsibility to uphold and protect the principle of neutrality is enormous — not just for the ICRC. The national Red Cross and Red Crescent societies would be impacted, along with many other international and national humanitarian organizations,” she added.

    And among those global rights organizations, Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch (HRW) have both come under ferocious criticism for their reports faulting not just Russia but also Ukraine for breaching the laws of war.

    For example, Ukraine is a signatory to the 1997 Anti-Personnel Mine Ban Convention — a treaty prohibiting any use of antipersonnel mines — and HRW has called Kyiv out for firing thousands of banned antipersonnel mines at Russian-occupied territory in last year’s savage battle for the city of Izium.

    Amnesty also prompted a firestorm of Ukrainian and Western indignation when it criticized the conduct of Ukraine’s armed forces, for endangering civilian lives by the way they were operating in some residential areas. The report led to the resignation of the head of Amnesty’s Kyiv office, Oksana Pokalchuk, who said her local team hadn’t been properly consulted over the report, which unwittingly “sounded like support for Russian narratives.” She added that while “seeking to protect civilians, this research instead became a tool of Russian propaganda.”

    However, neither Amnesty nor HRW have pulled their punches when it comes to Russia’s egregious misconduct. Both have documented assaults on civilian neighborhoods; gathered evidence of war crimes, torture and disappearances; and denounced the blocking of humanitarian assistance to civilians. That doesn’t assuage their critics, though, who for all intents and purposes argue that in a war pitting a highly vicious aggressor against a clearly aggrieved party, there can be no space for any impartiality or neutrality at any time.

    But there must be.


    Strict public neutrality is a key component in getting the ICRC as much access to prisoners of war (POWs) as it can negotiate with belligerents, or has the capacity to handle. Amnesty and HRW reports would not be taken seriously — nor would they have the influence they do — if either failed to impartially call out anyone breaching international humanitarian law, which has been developed over decades in a bid to try and maintain some humanity during armed conflict, save lives and reduce suffering.

    Without these watchdogs, international humanitarian law — setting out what can be done and what shouldn’t be done during armed conflict — would collapse.

    Autocratic bullies sneer at humanitarian law and the idea of universal rights. The International Criminal Court’s recent arrest warrant for Russian President Vladimir Putin didn’t dissuade China’s Xi Jinping from visiting Moscow. And the vision he outlined in his Global Civilization Initiative is the very opposite of what the international community led by the West has attempted since 1945 — to shape a world of universal rights and values.

    Instead, Xi argued nations should “refrain from imposing their own values or models on others and from stoking ideological confrontation.” The world should be left to the great powers to balance their interests and all diplomacy should be transactional, with leaders like Xi, Putin and former United States President Donald Trump practicing the art of the deal.

    But Western governments have a vested interest in observing some space for neutrality and impartiality, to be respectful of humanitarians even when saying things they don’t like — just as U.N. human rights monitors did this week in their first full look at the treatment of POWs during the Ukraine war. Having interviewed about 400 POWs, both those held by Russia and Ukraine, they documented about 40 summary executions, as well as torture.

    “We are deeply concerned about the summary execution of up to 25 Russian prisoners of war and persons ordered to combat by Ukrainian armed forces, which we have documented,” Matilda Bogner, head of the U.N. monitoring mission, said. Bogner did emphasize that Russia’s invasion was at the root of this violence against civilians and POWs, adding that while Ukrainian prosecutors were investigating some cases, none had been taken to court yet.

    The UN rights office also documented five cases in which Ukrainian POWs had died after being tortured by their Russian captors or otherwise ill-treated, and four cases of death due to a lack of medical attention during internment.

    In response, the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry thanked the mission for documenting Russia’s violations of international law, but it pushed back on Ukraine’s abuses, arguing, “we consider it unacceptable to place responsibility on the victim of aggression. According to the U.N. Charter, Ukraine has the right to self-defense.”

    However, the fact remains that if we are to see off China and Russia’s efforts to reshape the world in their likeness, we need to keep faith with our values and respect neutrality — not make exceptions.


    Subscribe to our Telegram channel

Read also

Pakistan refuses to participate in Ukraine Peace Summit in Switzerland

13 June 2024 - 21:09

Pope Francis to meet world leaders at G7 Summit, marking a historic first

13 June 2024 - 21:21

Russia urges Armenia to stop “endless fuss” around Collective Security Treaty Organisation

13 June 2024 - 20:14

Erdogan concerned over rise of Islamophobia in Europe Post-EU parliament elections

13 June 2024 - 20:37

Western countries hasten delivery of F-16s to Ukraine

13 June 2024 - 20:22

G7 set to announce new Ukraine loan agreement

13 June 2024 - 19:13
Latest news

    Chinese trader’s $20 million pile of Russian copper goes missing

    14 June 2024 - 01:03

    Azerbaijani president's aide engages in political dialogue at NATO headquarters

    13 June 2024 - 23:46

    Oil drops on inventory build

    13 June 2024 - 23:02

    Azerbaijan, Japan discuss student exchange programmes


    13 June 2024 - 21:32

    Pope Francis to meet world leaders at G7 Summit, marking a historic first

    13 June 2024 - 21:21

    Pakistan refuses to participate in Ukraine Peace Summit in Switzerland

    13 June 2024 - 21:09

    Kuwait’s residents view Azerbaijan’s tourism potential at Tourism and Travel Exhibition

    13 June 2024 - 21:01

    Azerbaijan, Estonia mull bilateral cooperation during political consultations

    13 June 2024 - 20:55

    Belarus Foreign Ministry slams Armenian PM's statements as "shortsighted"

    13 June 2024 - 20:51

    EU proposes Azerbaijani gas transit to Europe via Ukraine

    13 June 2024 - 20:45

    Erdogan concerned over rise of Islamophobia in Europe

    Post-EU parliament elections

    13 June 2024 - 20:37

    Azerbaijani, Uzbek ruling parties forge strategic partnership

    13 June 2024 - 20:30

    Western countries hasten delivery of F-16s to Ukraine

    13 June 2024 - 20:22

    Russia urges Armenia to stop “endless fuss” around Collective Security Treaty Organisation

    13 June 2024 - 20:14

    Türkiye “neutralizes” 30 terrorists over past week


    13 June 2024 - 20:08

    Secretariat: Armenia - still member of Collective Security Treaty Organisation

    13 June 2024 - 19:54

    US embassy urges Armenian protestors to exercise right to freedom of assembly

    13 June 2024 - 19:51

    Russia rehearses delivering tactical nuclear weapons with dummy warheads

    13 June 2024 - 19:40

    Media: Azerbaijan, Iran conduct joint anti-terror drills


    13 June 2024 - 19:26

    US-Armenia strategic partnership a misstep in Southern Caucasus policy

    US pundit tells Caliber.Az

    13 June 2024 - 19:20

    G7 set to announce new Ukraine loan agreement

    13 June 2024 - 19:13

    Armenian PM underestimates leader of Belarus

    Experts’ opinions at Caliber.Az

    13 June 2024 - 19:05

    Minister: Azerbaijani gas provided roughly 20% of Greece's consumption in 2023


    13 June 2024 - 18:59

    Kyiv gets nearly $100 billion-worth weapons from NATO since start of war

    13 June 2024 - 18:58

    France’s rights violations in New Caledonia highlight its resistance to UN decolonization efforts - BIG director

    13 June 2024 - 18:45

    FM: French remilitarisation exacerbates crisis in New Caledonia

    13 June 2024 - 18:44

    US, Ukrainian presidents to sign 10-year security deal at G-7 summit

    13 June 2024 - 18:29

    IOC urges to help overturn French headscarves ban at Olympics

    13 June 2024 - 18:14

    Azerbaijan sets terms for USA, EU, & Armenia in South Caucasus geopolitics

    Baku opens the Zangazur Corridor

    13 June 2024 - 18:00

    Kyrgyzstan dismantles international cybercrime ring involving Chinese nationals

    13 June 2024 - 17:48

    Türkiye confirms deal to buy US F-16s

    13 June 2024 - 17:36

    Tourist flow to Azerbaijan approaching pre-pandemic level

    13 June 2024 - 17:24

    Canada to send thousands rocket engines to Ukraine

    13 June 2024 - 16:59

    Kremlin reacts to Pashinyan's statement to Lukashenko

    13 June 2024 - 16:46

    Macron's political earthquake: France at crossroads amidst unprecedented crisis

    Navigating turbulent waters of Fifth Republic

    13 June 2024 - 16:33

    Kremlin seeks clarification on Yerevan's CSTO position

    13 June 2024 - 16:20

    Israel strikes 45 targets across Gaza Strip


    13 June 2024 - 16:07

    Azerbaijan Airlines’ department, leading air navigation service providers sign agreement


    13 June 2024 - 15:45

    Turkish MPs to visit Azerbaijan’s Shusha

    13 June 2024 - 15:41

    Azerbaijan’s GDP reaches nearly $30 billion as of late May

    13 June 2024 - 15:28

All news