Garabagh teaches harsh lessons to those who accepted a ‘"frozen conflict"
Opinion by Nick Powell
KARABAKH 21 September 2023 - 15:38
By agreeing to surrender their weapons, Armenian rebels in the Garabagh region of Azerbaijan have ended their attempt to create a breakaway state. Although a so-called ‘frozen conflict’ enabled them to hold out for decades, their final defeat was swift, sudden, and ultimately inevitable in the face of Azerbaijan’s determination to reassert sovereignty over its sovereign territory.
Even frozen conflicts do not last forever. Russia, the United States, and the European Union should have been shaken out of their complacency in 2020, when Azeri forces liberated all parts of their country that had been under Armenian occupation, with the exception of part of Kararabakh.
This mountainous and beautiful region, considered to be the Azeris’ cultural heartland, has long had Armenians living there. But it had always been recognised as part of Azerbaijan, both by the Soviet Union and by the entire international community after independence from Moscow.
Ever since the fighting in 2020, Azerbaijan has been entirely clear that it would not accept any alternative to the complete reintegration of the whole of Garabagh. But just as it had suited Russia, the United States, and the EU to tolerate the occupation of Azeri territory for decades, so the same complacency returned after the conflict. Any wish for true peace was outweighed by the misguided belief that it was enough to avoid all-out war.
It is tempting to observe that when all three are in agreement, that’s all one needs to know to realise that a situation is unsustainable and probably just plain wrong. However, it’s worth noting their motives. In Russia’s case, it was a wish to maintain influence in the South Caucasus by providing peacekeeping forces. For the United States, there was an opportunity to cultivate Armenia and undermine Russian influence.
The European Union’s approach could be described as more nuanced if one was being very polite. Divided and confused would be another way of putting it. The President of the European Council, Charles Michel, found a role as an honest broker, hosting a series of meetings between President Ilham Aliyev of Azerbaijan and Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan of Armenia.
Speaking to me and other journalists in the liberated city of Shusha in July, President Aliyev was kind enough to praise President Michel’s “supplementary and supportive” efforts, even as the Russian and American processes, so essential to avoiding further conflict, were undermined by their rivalry for influence in Armenia.
The EU did itself no favours when its High Representative, Josep Borell, responded to the renewed fighting by not merely calling for a cessation of hostilities but demanding that Azerbaijan “stop the current military activities”, without similarly addressing the armed actions of rebel forces supported by Armenia.
The Azeri Ministry of Foreign Affairs deplored the EU statement and defended its right to respond to military provocations and terror attacks by illegal Armenian armed forces. Azerbaijan’s Ambassador to the European Union, Vaqif Sadiqov, pointed out that hostilities were being ceased through the elimination of Armenian military outposts and installations.
He warned that although the Azerbaijan army’s counter-terrorism measures were of limited scope after deadly attacks against Azeri police and civilians, the Armenian military had to lay down their arms and surrender “or face the consequences”, adding that this was as true for Azerbaijan as it would be for any other country facing a similar threat to its sovereignty.
A ceasefire after 24 hours means that the death toll could be less than 100 on both sides, a figure that will probably be exceeded by the casualties from the millions of mines that the Armenians planted in and around Garabagh. They have been unable -or unwilling- to provide accurate maps of the minefields.
Prime Minister Pashinyan cuts a forlorn figure. Defeated when Azerbaijan liberated most of the occupied territory in 2020, he has explicitly recognised that Armenia has no legitimate claim to Azeri territory and implicitly that his country has run out of allies in aiding the rebels.
But for as long as the world, in the shape of Russia, the US, and the EU, saw no need to tell him that the game was up and that a so-called frozen conflict (actually involving escalating tension) couldn’t be spun out for a few more years. In such circumstances, he could never persuade the Armenian people, let alone the rebels in Garabagh, that it was time to negotiate a peace treaty.
For Azerbaijan, the challenge now is to successfully reintegrate its Armenian population, though some may prefer to leave. For the EU in particular, it’s time to not just seek a stable partner in Azerbaijan as a supplier of oil and gas but to support stability and peace throughout the South Caucasus.
It’s a region of crucial importance both in its own right and as a trade route between Europe and Asia. A peace treaty, with the reopening of borders to trade and cooperation, is a prize that will take patience and perseverance; though better that form of patience than tolerating a frozen conflict for decades, quietly hoping that it would never end.
Lachin City before Armenian occupation Rare archive footage/VIDEO
Azerbaijan's ANAMA defuses hundreds of landmines in liberated lands in November Including over 4,100 UXOs
Shusha hosts "Common Turkic Cuisine" event PHOTO
Azerbaijani police find ammunition abandoned by Armenians in Tartar PHOTO
International scientific conference to be held in Shusha
Azerbaijan to launch admission to Karabakh University from 2024
Azerbaijan rules out second chance for OSCE to reconcile Baku and Yerevan There will be no second chance
02 December 2023 - 10:23
Ilham Aliyev is right - Azerbaijan has more friends in CSTO than Armenia does Armenian politician says
01 December 2023 - 13:48
Italian Deputy Minister reflects on fomenting Armenian revanchism in Europe
02 December 2023 - 16:44
Armenia's war crimes and the pursuit of justice in Azerbaijan Opinion by Taras Kuzio
02 December 2023 - 13:05
Azerbaijan to host prestigious World Urban Forum in 2026
01 December 2023 - 09:12
The Economist: World should pay to conserve rainforests
04 December 2023 - 00:01
Pakistan: Will elections take place on time?
03 December 2023 - 22:02
Is South Korea Disappearing?Opinion by The New York Times
03 December 2023 - 20:01
Pentagon: US arms industry struggling to keep up with China
03 December 2023 - 18:30
Poland plans to supply Ukraine with new batch of self-propelled howitzers
03 December 2023 - 18:16
Bavarian premier calls for halt to welfare payments to new Ukrainian refugees
03 December 2023 - 18:00
Pope deplores end of Israel-Hamas truce, voices hope for new ceasefire
03 December 2023 - 17:51
Azerbaijan's Energy Minister to attend events within COP28 in Dubai
03 December 2023 - 17:40
Israel widens evacuation orders as it shifts its offensive to southern Gaza
03 December 2023 - 17:32
Israel launches strikes, orders evacuations in Southern Gaza
03 December 2023 - 17:20
Air raid alert declared in Ukraine
03 December 2023 - 17:08
Hamas kills Israeli soldiers in Beit Hanoun
03 December 2023 - 16:56
EU ambassador praises Georgia’s efforts towards European integration
03 December 2023 - 16:44
WHO chief: Humanitarian situation in Gaza -staggering
03 December 2023 - 16:32
UAE to allocate $150 million for water security solutions
03 December 2023 - 16:20
Azerbaijani delegation attending World Media Summit in ChinaPHOTO
03 December 2023 - 16:08
Over 2,500 trucks queue at Polish-Ukrainian border
03 December 2023 - 15:57
Georgian expert: Only Azerbaijan can save Armenia from current situation
03 December 2023 - 15:46
Israeli military shells Syria after detecting rocket fire from that country
03 December 2023 - 15:34
France continues to arm Armenia
03 December 2023 - 15:21
Türkiye plans to remove over 140 of citizens from Gaza
03 December 2023 - 15:09
Israel uses AI "Gospel" to strike Hamas
03 December 2023 - 14:57
UN special rapporteur must correct gross mistakeStatement by Western Azerbaijan Community
03 December 2023 - 14:46
Japan starts offering "quasi-refugee" status to people fleeing conflicts
03 December 2023 - 14:37
Ombudswoman: Armenia’s disabled citizens continue to face many problems
03 December 2023 - 14:25
Azerbaijani figure skater takes first place at international competitions
03 December 2023 - 14:13
Countries vow to triple global nuclear energy by 2050
03 December 2023 - 14:02
Turkish police nab Interpol-wanted senior member of criminal group operating in RussiaVIDEO
03 December 2023 - 13:53
US defense chief says Israel will only win in Gaza if civilians are protected
03 December 2023 - 13:41
US earns over 50 billion euros from gas sales to EU
03 December 2023 - 13:29
Belarus President Lukashenko heading to China second time this year
03 December 2023 - 13:17
Minister: Investments in environmental projects in Azerbaijan's liberated lands discussed in DubaiPHOTO
03 December 2023 - 13:05
Armenians leave Karabakh due to ethnic hatred towards AzerbaijanStatement by Western Azerbaijan Community
03 December 2023 - 12:54
Paraguayan lawmaker, three others die in plane crash
03 December 2023 - 12:42
US to deploy new ground-based missiles to Indo-Pacific in 2024
03 December 2023 - 12:33
NATO Secretary General urges to prepare for worsening conflict in Ukraine
03 December 2023 - 12:21
COP28: Azerbaijan's role in global fight against climate crisisAnalysis by Caliber.Az
03 December 2023 - 12:09
At least 11 people killed in armed attack in Pakistan
03 December 2023 - 11:58
US Air Force Secretary: Military needs AI to augment human capabilities
03 December 2023 - 11:50
US House close to vote on Biden impeachment inquiry, speaker says
03 December 2023 - 11:41