US floats new steel, aluminium tariffs based on carbon emissions

US officials are proposing to levy tariffs on steel and aluminium based on how much carbon the producing country's industries emit, in a bid to fight climate change and "dirty" metals made in China and elsewhere, two people familiar with the plan said on December 7.

The proposal from the US Trade Representative's office to be negotiated with the European Union would create a global "club" of market-oriented countries seeking to reduce carbon emissions. The plan would set "emissions intensity" standards for the production of specific steel and aluminium and products, according to a document describing the plan seen by Reuters.

Countries that are members of the "global arrangement" with emissions exceeding these standards would pay higher tariffs when exporting metals to countries with lower emissions, according to the document. Countries with steel and aluminium plant emissions at or below those of the importing country would pay no carbon-based tariffs.

“There would be an advantage of being in the club, as it would provide a lower level of carbon tariffs, while countries outside the club would pay higher tariffs,” one of the sources said, adding that the proposal aimed to incentivize investments to reduce emissions.

“This is all very conceptual and there’s a lot of work ahead on this. The details are going to be very important.”

Countries outside the low-emissions club would be subject to a higher rate of tariffs when exporting steel and aluminium to member countries.

The proposal, which is now being shared with industry and EU officials, has grown out of US-EU discussions on “green” steel production over the past year after Washington halted tariffs on EU-produced steel and aluminium in exchange for a quota system.

The two sides agreed to work to reduce carbon emissions in steel and aluminium production while tackling the longstanding problem of excess capacity in the industries, much of it centered in China.

The proposed low-emissions metals club would exclude China and other "non-market" economies dominated by state-owned or state-directed enterprises, setting out criteria to prohibit member countries from contributing to the problem of unviable excess steel and aluminium capacity.

A USTR spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the plan.

AIMED AT CHINA

US steelmakers claim to have the world's lowest carbon emissions levels, in part because 70 per cent of American steel is made from scrap iron in electric-arc furnaces rather than smelting iron ore in coal-fired blast furnaces. Steelmakers elsewhere, including in Europe, rely more heavily on coal, and the plan as proposed would be advantageous to US producers.

The US-EU talks on low-carbon steel have been aimed in large part at China, which relies on coal for most of its steel output as well as low-grade iron ore that contributes to high carbon emissions.

If implemented, the plan would provide new grounds for excluding Chinese steel from Western markets. Most US tariffs are currently based on anti-dumping laws to combat pricing below production costs, laws aimed at combating unfair government subsidies or laws aimed at safeguarding strategic industries.

But hurdles to the plan are significant. The EU has proposed a carbon border adjustment and carbon trading schemes that would be quite different from a simpler tariff proposed by the United States, so reconciling these different systems may take time.

And the Biden administration's legal authority for putting carbon-based tariffs in place is far from clear. Congress has constitutional jurisdiction over tariffs and other tax and spending matters, and the sources said the plan would almost certainly require legislation - an extremely difficult proposition for Biden with Repblicans taking control of the House of Representatives next year.