EU upholds free speech amid growing controversy over Musk's far-right AfD endorsement

The European Commission (EC) has opted not to comment on Ilon Musk's recent actions supporting the right-wing Alternative for Germany (AfD) party, with spokesperson Paula Pinho stating that any comment would only fuel further debate.

Pinho made this remark during an EC briefing in Brussels, addressing questions regarding Musk’s online engagement with the far-right political party, Caliber.Az reports via foreign media.

“This is our political choice, as we see that any comment only fuels this discussion,” Pinho explained.

Musk’s comments on the AfD have stirred considerable controversy. Alice Weidel, co-chair of the AfD and candidate for Chancellor of Germany, confirmed that she would engage in an online discussion with the US entrepreneur on January 9 via the social platform X. 

This follows Musk’s earlier expression of support for the party. In an article published in Welt am Sonntag, Musk warned that Germany’s future teetered on the edge of economic and cultural collapse, arguing that the AfD represents the "last spark of hope" for the nation. Musk had also previously posted on X, stating, "Only the AfD can save Germany." His remarks have led to widespread outrage, with many parties condemning his comments, and government spokeswoman Christiane Hoffman accusing Musk of attempting to interfere in Germany’s electoral process.

The European Commission’s stance on Musk’s actions appears to be grounded in support for freedom of expression. EC spokesperson Thomas Renier reaffirmed this position, stating that Musk, like any individual, is entitled to express his views. "Freedom of expression is at the heart of our digital act. Everyone has the right to express their opinion. This also applies to Ilon Musk," Renier said during a press briefing.

However, the European Commission has also indicated it is reviewing whether Musk’s online activities violate the EU’s digital community standards, particularly with regard to the promotion of his posts on X. Renier clarified that the EC is investigating if Musk's actions could breach EU regulations, though no official violations have been determined.

Musk’s remarks have not been limited to Germany. The entrepreneur also called for UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer to resign, accusing him of complicity in historical sexual offences against minors in northern England. Musk’s controversial comments on multiple issues have led to heightened scrutiny from European regulators, including the potential impact of his influence on political matters.

The controversy surrounding Musk's support for the AfD comes at a time when Europe's political landscape is seeing a shift in its handling of far-right parties. Traditionally, European Union countries have adhered to an unspoken principle known as the "cordon sanitaire," where mainstream political parties and media avoid engaging with or supporting far-right or far-left groups. This principle has been eroding in recent years, as right-wing parties have gained strength across Europe. Many experts believe this change signals a potential realignment of political norms, with more political entities and public figures engaging with far-right parties, a trend that has become increasingly apparent since 2020.

By Tamilla Hasanova